Cubuole's Heartgold Tileset Project

[Cubuole]

I am making a tileset for the new Heartgold and Soulsilver pokemon games.
please critique my work, I'm new to the community and would like feedback.
I will try to update whenever I can, you can use these tiles in any way, just please give credit to me!

Reply to H20 Turquoise: No, I did not rip them, I made them myself.
Reply to Everyone: YES I DID MAKE THEM, if the pallette looks the same, it should, because I used the HG/SS PALLETTE, other than that, they ARE handmade: That means I did not rip them.
(thanks for the compliment Proffesor Layton and tainiu)
(if people are fighting over whether i made them or not, that must mean Im good)

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

You should try doing some basic outlines... Basically what you did was just rip them from a ROM. Am I right?

 

[FinalEclipse]

these are some damn good tiles they really have a 3d effect some hgss tiles look like they were caught in a compactor

 

[TB Pro]

Reply to H20 Turquoise: No, I did not rip them, I made them myself.

Sorry, but this is lies. You most certainly did not make them, you ripped them and edited them. Like H20 said, you need to add an outline. They're not too bad for a beginner, but without an outline, they lack so much.

 

[Omega Zero]

I am making a tileset for the new Heartgold and Soulsilver pokemon games.
please critique my work, I'm new to the community and would like feedback.
I will try to update whenever I can, you can use these tiles in any way, just please give credit to me!

Reply to H20 Turquoise: No, I did not rip them, I made them myself.

These tiles are so beautiful I love them 8)

 

[onyx79]

you should change the tiles they are not good for a 3rd gen game...

 

[874521]

you should change the tiles they are not good for a 3rd gen game...

I agree, it's like you ripped them but I know the HGSS tiles doens't look like that except if you access the 2D code for that. Add the outline so that hackers may use them in their hack.

 

[Andrew McKenzie]

you should change the tiles they are not good for a 3rd gen game...

First things first, whilst he does need to fix them to a 2D view, he doesn't need to do them for a 3rd gen game.
He doesn't have to allow people to use what he rips for their hacks.
If he ripped them, he decides whether or not you can use them, because he put the effort into ripping them.

Sorry, but this is lies. You most certainly did not make them, you ripped them and edited them. Like H20 said, you need to add an outline. They're not too bad for a beginner, but without an outline, they lack so much.

Truth. You didn't make them from scratch, they're from the game.
You either ripped them or stole them from someone else who ripped them.

Add the outline so that hackers may use them in their hack.

Again. He doesn't have to allow hackers to use them in their hacks.
That's his choice, if he did rip them, or make them.
Because he sets the allowance. Failing that, there's loads of HGSS Tiles that people do allow you to use for whatever, with credit.
But he has no proof to either having ripped nor made them.

As it stands. I know you did not make them from scratch.
You either ripped them or stole them.
I hope you ripped them.

Fix the outline and view to 2D.