Did you find Whitney's Miltank easier in GSC or HGSS?

[Jeremy]

Well sweeties, I would say HGSS was easier, mostly I knew who I was facing, her Pokémon's levels were lower, and she didn't seem to use Roll Out as much for me.

 

[Wobbachomp]

Well I don't really remember much about GSC, I was really young when I played them... but I'd assume HGSS seeing as I wasn't very good at games back then.

 

[Are there Oceans in Space?]

I would say that I actually knew what I was doing by the time 4th generation rolled around haha. So I did level up my Pokemon more and knew how to handle the gym leaders, Whitney included.

 

[ZetaZaku]

She's only difficult for newcomers and children. I always had problems when I battled her when I was a kid. Last time I played Silver, she stood no chance. And all I did was use Croconaw's Rage. But I'd say that GSC was more difficult because the game evolved after that.

 

[chella182]

I found that in HGSS Whitney's Miltank seemed to be much less vicious, not so much spam on the Rollout and generally easier and at a lower level.​

This, pretty much. I remember having such bother with it in Gold (in fact, I think it took me about a month to get past it!), but in SoulSilver I got through first time.​

 

[Twilight-kun]

Mud-Slap (Lowers accuracy) x6
Growl (Lowers attack) x6
Tail Whip (Lowers defense) x6


what Miltank

Mud-Slap (Lowers accuracy) x6
Growl (Lowers attack) x6
Tail Whip (Lowers defense) x6


what Miltank

 

[Xanntha14]

In HGSS miltank was way to easy. In all honesty i would have loved it if miltank was harder in HGSS.

 

[mikey]

HGSS Milktank was much easier. I remember trying countless times in GSC to defeat that thing, and in HGSS it took me 2 tries.