4th Gen Gold and Silver remake

[Thunderdash]

if there do a G/S remake it should be on the GBA cause u can trade with Fr/Lg easy than if it was on DS

 

[ss5vegeta]

It should be on DS but dont use PAL park and can trade back.

 

[Bomberman]

One si ple reson: What was the first ever pokemon except Pikachu that we saw in the anime?

I thought it was Gengar :P

 

[Kirokusclone]

heres a thought, what if instead of goin to Kanto, you go to Hoenn?

 

[Pokemon Master D-P]

just get pokemon shiny gold

 

[Empires228]

They should make one but Change some of the things such as safari that were taken out because of glitches and not enough memory.

 

[Forci Stikane]

One si ple reson: What was the first ever pokemon except Pikachu that we saw in the anime?

Gengar, Nidorino, Onix, Bulbasaur, Charmander, Squirtle, Pidgey (in the form of a toy), Dodrio (I believe)...

Pidgey (for real this time), Rattata, Spearow, Mankey, and a few others...I think there was even a Gyarados in there...so, am I right?

Aswer: Ho-Oh.

......Boy, you were REALLY off.

It should be on DS but dont use PAL park and can trade back.

Uh, no. That could cause severe compatability problems, especially since R/S/E/FR/LG aren't programmed to be able to handle a Time Capsule-type thing (which is what it would have to be).

 

[ss5vegeta]

I dont realy care about trading, but they wouldent use a in game (obviously not real) time machine, D/P is set just before G/S because of the Red Gyarados report so D/P would of had to have a time machine.
That would mean G/S isant years after FR/LG, and Green and Red would of lookedalot older in the originals.

And the Safari zone should be unlocked after beating all 16 gyms and getting the National Dex it should house some Hoenn pokemon and another area should contain the 4th gen pokes.

 

[Kirokusclone]

then if you want the hownn and Sinnoh pokemon, their shuld either be the safari zone, plus another one, or prehaps an addition, much like what happened in emerald

 

[Taemin]

Man, if they really did make a remake of G/S/C the graphics might even be slightly better then the D/P graphics, because it probably wouldn't be out until like .... 2009. oO
Intresting to think about it...

I wish they would actually remake them, that'd be awesome... and more amusing then a Mystery Dungeon 2...

 

[~NeonFire~]

I wouldn't mind a remake of all the GBC and GBA games for DS, but I would much rather see new Pokemon games instead.

 

[typeZERO]

Gengar, Nidorino, Onix, Bulbasaur, Charmander, Squirtle, Pidgey (in the form of a toy), Dodrio (I believe)...

Pidgey (for real this time), Rattata, Spearow, Mankey, and a few others...I think there was even a Gyarados in there...so, am I right?



......Boy, you were REALLY off.



Uh, no. That could cause severe compatability problems, especially since R/S/E/FR/LG aren't programmed to be able to handle a Time Capsule-type thing (which is what it would have to be).

Hey don't forget the voltorb! (as a clock) And maybe the trading system would be just like D/P's? You know , insert game into gba slot and then trade from there (heck they could add the function where you insert a certain game and certain pokemon pop up in the wild. Just like D/P). And plus I wonder what the Johto and Kanto pokemon sprites will look like , since FR/LG had new Kanto sprites.

 

[Master Trainer Empoleon]

My cousin and I used to have extreme competitions. (I had Silver and Yellow,he had Red,Blue and Gold). His Typhlosion pwnd my Feralagatr. (It knew thunderpunch) My Umbreon pwnd his Espeon. His Scizor pwnd my Pidgeot. His Golem pwned my Macargo.
My Lugia pwnd his Ho-oh.



Anyways,I think a remake would be awesome,and insted of 1 or 2 rivals there should be 3 or 4 rivals.

 

[wmoor0826]

OK

there's not much of a point to make a johto remake. with a johto remake, they'll obviously have to add kanto to the game, and kanto has already been remade if you remember (FR/LG). also, ALL the pokemon can be caught in D/P except for a couple legendaries, Lugia and Ho-Oh, which can be caught on FR/LG with the necessary Nintendo Event item(s).

hate to break it to you, but there's just no point. the only explanation for the timeline reference to Johto is because they're trying to make the most sense out of the game -- they weren't going to include Kanto and Hoenn and just totally ignore Johto as if it's not an actual region in the world of Pokemon. remember, with D/P, they are trying to bring all of the elements of the game together, so they're including EVERYTHING into the games.

You can't catch every pokemon in d/p unless you have the older games like emerald or firered, which is hard for some people, because they sell the games or lose them after a while.

 

[idontnoWHOiam]

I would buy a GSC remake, but I would much rather have a new game. There are some pokemon you can only get through PalPark that I really wish you could catch in the wild, like magnemite/ton-->magnezone, but you can't even get your 3rd gen pokemon until you see every sinnoh pokemon :\

 

[Aquarain]

I wouldn't mind a G/S/C remake, I never really got to play the game(s) when they came out, so it would be great if they did make it, to have it in GBA or DS.

 

[J]

"lol were gonna make u a pkmn gsc remake so u can catch all teh gsc pkmn dat u got on ur emerald ver so we get all of ur money!!!1"

...Sounds logical to me.

 

[Stevo-kun]

Nah, I don't think they should remake it, I mean, G/S/C was okay. I still think R/B/Y and R/S/E where better and well, it wouldn't be fair remaking it for the DS when all the other one just got a GBA remake. Yes FR and LG where really good, a great trip back, and a great remake, but, I don't think they should remake any more of them and just continue making new ones instead of remaking old ones. Being as Pokemon is in a new era, it would seem unfair to bring back second Generation games on a 4th Generation Pokemon Game console.

 

[ChrisG14]

Well, we shall see in on April 14, this magazine Kokoro comics will be talking about a new Pokemon game. We know of the new Pokemon Ranger game, but that might not be the game in question. So we shall see...

 

[Mr.Altosax]

Personally, I believe that G/S/C was the best generation of pokemon so far. For one, you weren't "region locked", you didn't just have to stay in Johto you got to fight for the eight Kanto badges as well. Also they started the day/night feature, which hasn't been seen again until now. It's also the only game so far that brought in new types to the original mix. Where would we be now without Dark and Steel, or for that matter Umbreon and Espeon. The G/S brought in some of the greatest legendaries since Mewtwo, sure Rayquaza's cool but he's got nothing on Lugia, Ho-Oh, Celebi, or the Legendary dogs.

R/B/Y got their remix, so I definetely think that this one deserves theirs.