Graphic Rating Thread

[THIRTY-SIX]

now i like that icey effect, that came out, the font spoils it imo because it doesnt suit it
oh kyosuke you are the king of animated banner / sigs
ThePkmnMaster the pattern overlay should be a little lighter and not covering the image
​

 

[Geometric-sama]

The font's OK but its colour doesn't fit the rest of the banner and it's hard to read. The banner itself isn't too bad, but it's a touch choppy and feels a bit grainy. I'd say get rid of the lighter bar at the top too, it doesn't add anything and makes it feel like a badly-done bevel.

edit: posted late, this was a response to Roxas' sig.

 

[alangeds]

Jedi_Amara
9/10, Love that Avatar

 

[RoxasOld]

I made 2 new sets. Very simple, though. I think they look pretty good for something simple...

*needs to find new pictures XD*

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

D= what do you think of this D=

​

 

[alangeds]

Please rate, I don't think I did too well..

 

[Sawyer]

I like it, but I think your smudging is a bit too strong. Lower the strength to 80% maybe?

 

[alangeds]

Here's another 2 smudged sigs, but I don't like them, I think I should have re-sized the first render a bit more..

and

 

[Sawyer]

The 2nd one's pretty good, I like the text, but... the X smudge brush is way too visible. Is that X brush the one from my tutorial? If so, thanks for reading it =D

 

[alangeds]

Ehh.. Isn't the x effect nice?

 

[Sawyer]

The X's are just a bit too obvious in my opinion =/

 

[alangeds]

Which smudge effect should I go on with?

or

And which should I use?

 

[Sawyer]

second one's too smooth. Use the same shape dynamics, just lower the strength :P

 

[alangeds]

I made a banner without really following a tutorial, I got ideas from them, but didn't use the same settings.

And here's the one I made using AC's tutorial, the tut is really nice, but I just couldn't follow it properly, lol.

EDIT:
I made an account on Deviantart, check out my May/Haruka Vector I just made

Here

I have also shown the original picture there too.

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

that sephiroth banner really catches the eye...
the banner you made with sawyers tut is better than what i did D:
anyway can you rate this

especially the typography please =D

 

[Guest123_x1]

update! check it out!

A different renedition of my previous graphic that I posted for review.

 

[pokexproduction]

that sephiroth banner really catches the eye...
the banner you made with sawyers tut is better than what i did D:
anyway can you rate this

especially the typography please =D

9.5/10
I like how this one looks ^^

 

[Dragon-Chan]

*pokes siggy* My first actually good banner

 

[alangeds]

Well, you can draw nicely, but I's a bit too simple.

 

[Ejunknown]

Hiya, first time posting here. My graphix are in my sig and my avvy, *points* Made in Adobe Photoshop Elements, took 2 hours for the banner alone. :)