Well, it annoys me when people constantly make grammar mistakes. |:< *cough*mistacks*cough*
Anyway, I agree. I mean, just because he has a high level Pokemon does not mean hes Ash. He is labled Red by the game, thus he is Red. Just because he has the Pokemon you'd obtain in Yellow doesn't mean he's Ash, it is just a reference to Yellow (even though Yellow is based on the anime. XD)