pink magikarp vs shiny magikarp

[Mab]

which one do you prefer?

I just got my first pink and I've had two shinies before - I think I actually prefer the pink one. the colour is lovely.

 

[Radiating]

I've obtained one shiny one, but no pink one, but I've seen both.

I prefer the shiny one.

 

[Melody]

I only got one Shiny, I haven't gotten any Pink yet but I haven't been at it that long.

[Note:] I refuse to purchase any Diamonds with real money

 

[Spyro]

There's another one I prefer from both of these. But it seems to be endgame only so I won't spoil anything!

 

[Mab]

There's another one I prefer from both of these. But it seems to be endgame only so I won't spoil anything!

:0
gotta find out

 

[colter519]

There's another one I prefer from both of these. But it seems to be endgame only so I won't spoil anything!

I bet I know which one...and it's probably my favorite too.

 

[mishy.]

Pink is always better than gold.

 

[Nina]

[Note:] I refuse to purchase any Diamonds with real money

Diamonds do almost nothing to get you a shiny or pink one. Yes, you can insta fish with 10, but you can also get it purposely taken away if you're just trying to spam get karp till you get a pattern you want.