Please rate my banners

[Revolution]

Please Rate these for me.

Thank you

 

[Kelsh]

I really like the Dawn one the most; it's really nice!

 

[babyshuppet_666]

Ooh, really cool! What program do you use? photoshop?

 

[RYOUKI]

that's a cool banner! but...
the 1st one, I can't clearly see the Text...7/10
the 2nd one, It's too empty...9/10
the 3rd one, it's soo Dark...5/10

 

[Pikabloo]

Okay, I'll try not to sound too mean O_o:

1 - Let's go over the good things, first. Let me see... Okay, the colours of the background and the text match nicely to the colours of the render. However, the render itself seems to be very rough; the edges are pixelated, and there are sections of the sword that he is holding which is missing. Also, I don't think the lowered opacity on the render works very well, and, just like what Ryouki said, the text is hard to read. 6/10

2 - This one is better. The text is good, and the colours match, for the most part. However, I don't think the lowered opacity on Dawn works well, and the rendering is rough. Furthermore, the small section with Piplup looks... Out of place, mainly because of the colours. 6.5/10

3 - I personally think this is the best out of the three. The colours, once again, match, and the rendering of the image is very good. I still don't think the lowered opacity of the render works right, but it isn't as obvious in this one as it is in the others. I'm not a fan of 3D text, though... But it's still a good banner ^^ 7/10

 

[Shinji_]

I like the Dawn and Piplup. Although the negative side to it is the background colour is too dull it would of been MUCH better if you had made it brighter =P

 

[BluePhoenix]

I'll go real easy on you...

1: I go with Shiranui and Ryouki. The render's a bit too rough, and well, Yellow is a bright color and it hits the eye, the background is good, but the color isn't a good one. Also, it's noticeable that part of the sword is missing, you might have picked the wrong picture for the one. Rating: 5/10 - Sorry...

2: This one's way better than the last one, but the picture just doesn't match with the banner, you should have just got a no bg one and put it up there beside Dawn. I like the text and the back ground. I give you a 7/10

3: I really like this one. The best of all three. I like the colors and the way you made it. The text looks good too. And like Shiranui said, the rendering of the image goes pretty well with the banner! I think in this one I'll give you: 8.5/10

Personally, I don't like light colors like Yellow, so I kinda gave you low marks there and I like dark colors so 1.5 more marks there ;)

 

[babyshuppet_666]

You're all so mean at this forum! Why do you have to critisize so much?? You could courage people instead of always thinking of negative things. (and I don't mean people on this thread, I mean the art threads in general)

Yeah I know I already commented on your sigs but I really have to say that I love the second one with Dawn and piplup ^o^

 

[BluePhoenix]

Uh, you know we are not really mean =3

When we criticize someone, we actually tell him what things to improve on, so instead of taking it all negatively, the person should take it as a comment...or an advice. This helps him to improve in his own work!

We are also not saying that it's crap or something XD His sigs are good! We just pointed out the things he should improve on to make them look better! =)

 

[babyshuppet_666]

Uh, you know we are not really mean =3

When we criticize someone, we actually tell him what things to improve on, so instead of taking it all negatively, the person should take it as a comment...or an advice. This helps him to improve in his own work!

We are also not saying that it's crap or something XD His sigs are good! We just pointed out the things he should improve on to make them look better! =)

yup, i know. that's why i said i don't only mean this thread.