Cool, can I answer?
Awesome.
I think the names of the brothers are those elements: fire, water, air and I forget the last one.
I think the one that runs is water because water...runs, lol, the one that eats is fire because it burns everything and never wants to stop, the one that drinks is...I don't know, and the one that sings is air because on a windy day the air outside "sings" but it's really annoying.
Let me do one!
There are three people in front of you. You know that:
-One of them is God; he knows everything and always tells the truth.
-One of them is the Devil; he also knows everything but always lies.
-The third person knows nothing but answers questions as if he knows the answers. His answers, however, are completely useless and could be right or wrong.
You can ask a total of three questions that can be answered with yes or no, each to one of the persons. You may choose who to ask and you may ask more than one question to the same person.
Determine who is who...
EDIT: Sorry, were you supposed to tell me if I was right before I posted the new riddle?
EDIT: Alrightly, here's the solution.
To make life simple, I'm going to call God G, Devil D and the random one R.
These are the possible ways they could be arranged when you see them standing side by side.
GDR
GRD
DGR
DRG
RGD
RDG
The questions should be asked about where they are positioned.
I asked the following questions, but you could use a slightly different one to start off with:
Question 1
Is R immediately to the right of D? (asked to the person on the left)
If they answered yes:
GDR
DGR
RGD
RDG
If they answered no:
GRD
DRG
RGD
RDG
If they answered yes to this question then R cannot be in the middle. If they answered no then R cannot be on the right.
Question 2Y (only asked provided that the answer to Question 1 was yes)
Are you R? (asked to the person in the middle)
If they answered yes:
GDR
RDG
If they answered no:
DGR
RGD
If they answered yes, D must be in the middle because we know that R is not in the middle and we know D always lies. If they answered no, G must be in the middle because we know R is not in the middle and G always tells the truth.
Question 2N (only asked provided that the answer to Question 1 was no)
Are you R? (asked to the person on the right)
If they answered yes:
GRD
RGD
If they answered no:
DRG
RDG
If they answered yes, D must be on the right because we know R is not on the right and D always lies. If they answered no, G must be on the right because we know R is not on the right and G always tells the truth.
Question 3YY (only asked provided that the answers to the two previous questions were both yes)
Is the person on the right G? (asked to the person in the middle)
If they answered yes:
GDR
If they answered no:
RDG
Question 3YN (asked only provided that the answers to the two previous questions were yes and no respectively)
Is the person on the right D? (asked to the person in the middle)
If they answered yes:
RGD
If they answered no:
DGR
Question 3NY (asked only provided that the answers to the two previous questions were no and yes respectively)
Is the person in the middle G? (asked to the person on the right)
If they answered yes:
GRD
If they answered no:
RGD
Question 3NN (asked only provided that the answers to the two previous questions were both no)
Is the person in the middle D? (asked to the person on the right)
If they answered yes:
RDG
If they answered no:
DRG
Summary
Y = yes and N = no to each of the questions respectively.
YYY = GDR
YYN = RDG
YNY = RGD
YNN = DGR
NYY = GRD
NYN = RGD
NNY = RDG
NNN = DRG
Or, if you prefer, you can look at this diagram I drew on paint:
Hopefully I didn't make any typing errors with all the Gs, Ds, and Rs lol.