[Spoilers] Should Ash have won the kalos league?

[weedle_mchairybug]

orange league isn't an official league, so it doesn't count.
unless you wanna pull some bull**** theory out of your ass?

Well, it's certainly closer to an actual league than the Battle Frontier, at least. And how exactly is it not an official league? It not being in the games? By that logic, the Silver Conference isn't an official league either, since there IS no Johto League in the games (in GSC, not to mention the remake HGSS, you actually had to go to the Indigo Plateau in Kanto to do the Pok?mon League).

 

[Diamond 97]

It was silly to have him lose, IMO. It was the league where he had a really good team. He defeated really strong opponents. And Ash was easily in his best form in Kalos. And it seriously stings when he lost in the finals....I liked all the battles in Kalos.

Also, Greninja did several attacks on Charizard, and Pikachu did a couple of super-effective electric attacks on it too, so the logic of Charizard beating Greninja was poor.

 

[nl4real]

Ironic that Ash ended up winning the league in the generation immediately after (even if the Alola League isn't "official" or what have you), and still stuck around for one more. Personally, I don't have strong feelings one way or the other about how it should've shook out.