4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[Bao]

definitely soulsilver since i got the original silver and i prefer lugia over ho-oh

 

[Season]

Heart Gold. I like Ho-Oh much better than Lugia.
Gold was also the one I bought first when Gold and Silver came out. I liked buying the under dog version. :P

 

[Haunter54]

I liked buying the under dog version. :P

Lol, I always did the same thing.

 

[power321]

hmm. I got Gold and Silver for Christmas. :D That was so long ago..I don't know which to choose. I liked the Silver sprites better than the Gold one. lol. I may get both HG and SS. idk Or maybe I'll get SS?

 

[.Ozymandias]

I'll be getting SoulSilver as a pre-order as soon as I can, because Silver was my first second generation game way back when. I might get HeartGold later on, like I did with Pearl after Diamond, but we'll see.

 

[Meepman]

I'm getting heart gold because Ho-oh is under appreciated, MINORITIES FTW! Seriously both games got more votes than heart gold, that's just..........dang, is Ho-oh really that bad people?

 

[Jack Surge]

I have the Japanese Heart Gold, but I'll be getting the English Soul Silver, just because Silver was my first pokemon game ever. Nothing against Ho-oh.

 

[Zodiac Realm]

well im getting heart gold because i haven't even played the first gold plus ho-oh is one of my favorite Pokemon.

 

[Dark Shade]

I wanna get both, but soulsilver first.

 

[Dawn]

HeartGold here. :3 It was the 2nd gen game I had.

 

[Kai13]

Silver was my option some years ago, Silver will be my option this time too. I still remember when I was in the kindergarden, almost all my friends bought gold, I bought silver thinking I'd be the only one (I ended up not being the only one, though).

 

[Dawn]

It's odd that nobody has an overwhelming urge to "try something new" so to speak.

My observation is that the most common reason given is that Silver or Gold was the 2nd gen game they got originally.

 

[GengarNightmare]

My observation is that the most common reason given is that Silver or Gold was the 2nd gen game they got originally.

Maybe...... but a lot of people like Soul Silver better because they like Lugia more than Ho-oh (which includes me!). That's probably why they bought Silver in the first place.

Anyways, I bought both last time, and I'm buying both this time! The first time was because I knew there would be version exlcusives. However, this time, between D/P/Pt and the GBA games, you can all the pokemon without needing both HG and SS. The reason I'm getting both this time is because 1.)I like how trading Groudon/Kyogre to the other game makes Rayquaza show up (so cool!) 2.)Together, I'll no longer need to mess with GBA games so much and 3.)Having two means I can restart one as much as I want and still have a "main file".

And besides, I've always bought both, anyway. I'd feel like I'm missing a piece of the puzzle if I didn't buy both!

I still have all the main games, BTW. It's getting harder and harder to keep up with them, though, because they get stored away for years and I forget where they are! :P I finally decided to keep the GBC games in my "Fire Red" box, and the GBA ones are in a pouch made for GBA games.

Ironically, the only one I ever lost was Silver <-----My favorite game =/ (but I bought a replacement, so it's okay)

 

[Obi-Wan Jerkobi]

Soul Silver. <3 L70 Ho-oh, hecks yeah!

 

[gregory_turner420]

both just cuz im nerd like that

 

[azaria]

I'll get both, play one through without cheating or anything, as one of the trainers. Then, hack the other one and play as the other trainer. I usually do that, haha!

 

[Benjamin Owns]

I played crystal first :)

 

[Lv.100 ho-oh]

thank you all for voting :Di rlly am happy ill pick heartgold idk y but who cares have fun :D

 

[lv.100 Lugia]

Lugia pwns ho-oh so i like soul silver better and theres more things to do! :D

 

[RegisteelX]

Soul Silver :)
lugia PWNS