Okay people, this is getting out of hand. One of the rules here at PC is to respect all members, and both of you are disregarding this.
If you don't think a person's work is that good, there is no need to be so harsh in your criticism. Even though it's over the Internet, the person still has feelings and this sort of 'attack' in a post can leave them feeling hurt. Criticism is fine, but it doesn't need to be so harshly worded. Constructive criticism is always the best criticism.
This could rapidly degenerate into a flame war. If you have a personal disagreement, it is much better to share it over PM than to take it onto the forums, where it comes across as spam.
I will be keeping an eye on this thread - please do not continue this argument here.
--FG