Surgery complete...Now to check the Results...

[sims796]

I meant to say insulting, but I put Shine's post in consideration. So I said his wasn't helpful, but didn't bother to change it.

 

[bossman34]

i agree shinespike's posts were not usefule AFTER the first 1 or 2. but i do think squarewalker's posts were fine though. nothing wrong with pointing out weaknesses.

i gave your team an 8. i cant think of anything that will help =/. seems fine to me.

 

[sims796]

Yes. My apologies to Square.

 

[Shinespike]

Actually all of my posts were helpful. I said the team couldn't really get any better because he won't change the Pokemon which defeats the point of an RMT. This tread was pointless the second he decided that.

Favorite teams are pointless to rate because they are bound to lose to good well made teams. That is my point. It should have been pretty easy to tell that but you guys apparently can't see that, so I had to type out this tl;dr post for you to understand it.

 

[Smarties-chan]

Actually all of my posts were helpful. I said the team couldn't really get any better because he won't change the Pokemon which defeats the point of an RMT. This tread was pointless the second he decided that.

Favorite teams are pointless to rate because they are bound to lose to good well made teams. That is my point. It should have been pretty easy to tell that but you guys apparently can't see that, so I had to type out this tl;dr post for you to understand it.

I completely agree with you, but the point is that telling him the same thing over and over again won't help when he's adamant on not making any real improvements to his team. =\

 

[Shinespike]

Well then he's too thick to realize it.

So lock the pointless thread.

 

[sims796]

So your BOTH saying a team can't be well made and with favs? Amazing. I can't find that to be true at all. That means there's no point in playing the 493-minus ubers-if only 30 or so can be played "to win". You can be very sucessful with a team made of favs. Any good player (not that you are bad) can tell you that.

 

[Smarties-chan]

Well then he's too thick to realize it.

So lock the pointless thread.

As a matter of fact, I think will. This thread has become more of a ''ZOMG! Shinespike and Squarewalker r mean cuz they're giving the thread starter constructive criticism'' thread rather than an rmt.

So your BOTH saying a team can't be well made and with favs? Amazing. I can't find that to be true at all. That means there's no point in playing the 493-minus ubers-if only 30 or so can be played "to win". You can be very sucessful with a team made of favs. Any good player (not that you are bad) can tell you that.

I'm not saying a team made of favorites can't be good, I'm just saying a good team will destroy a team made of favorites. A team consisting of Pichu, Minun, Plusle, Togetic, Banette and Dragonair won't beat a good team no matter how much you love them. And you just contradicted yourself by saying a good player knows a team of favorites can be effective, while also saying that those who don't think so are good players as well. Make up your mind. ._.

And to prevent further off-topicness, this thread is now Closed