• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

The Extreme Gym

Status
Not open for further replies.
ito is pretty good, you better watch out swapslaking
 
I think he has beat him once before
 
swapslaking said:
Actually I want to battle Ito for his position , I just need 3 consecutive wins over him in order to do so
Click to expand...
Wait.is he allowed to battle a brain for there position without even collecting all the gym badges or crystals?That seems to kill the point of having ranks
 
In that case you cant challenge a E4 for the spot unitll you have all 8 badges?
 
Your allowed to take anyone's position in any rank.
 
The rules on the front page weren't specific about taking a fronteir brain's position. They do say that you must win 3 times consecutively to take a gym leader or elite 4's position. I guess I should not have assumed that the same applied to fronteir brains. I was not trying to cause rancour.

Shin Akuma said:
Wait.is he allowed to battle a brain for there position without even collecting all the gym badges or crystals?That seems to kill the point of having ranks
Click to expand...
 
swapslaking said:
The rules on the front page weren't specific about taking a fronteir brain's position. They do say that you must win 3 times consecutively to take a gym leader or elite 4's position. I guess I should not have assumed that the same applied to fronteir brains. I was not trying to cause rancour.
Click to expand...

then go for the final open Frontier Brain position!
 
No because your taking someone's position. Saying your tough enough to take one of there positions. I just fogot to put taking over a Frontier's spot as well. Remember I added this. It wasn't originally on.
 
Super Smash Kid said:
No because your taking someone's position. Saying your tough enough to take one of there positions. I just fogot to put taking over a Frontier's spot as well. Remember I added this. It wasn't originally on.
Click to expand...

Ok then explain the point of Frontier and elite 4 if anyone can just battle them by saying there good enough to take there position?I mean there is a final positon that swapslaking can go for but whats the point if he gets the postion and somebody comes by and challenges him for it 5 minutes later?I thought elite 4 and frontier meant you were really good thus can only have there postion taken by somebody that actually earned the right.not just run up and battle for it off the bat
 
No, SSK they're right, the right to battle the Elite 4 and the Frontier should be earned.
 
It seems that my challenge for Ito's position is inadverdantly causing rancour. Since Shin and Darkspace aren't in agreement with SSK's decision I won't battle Ito for his position. It isn't like I am allowed to win 3 times out of 100. I half to beat him 3 times in a row and losing once before winning 3 times would mean that I would have to start over against him completely. I won't try and use the rules to my advantage if it upsets the majority , I am not like Waluigi.
 
Last edited:
swapslaking said:
It seems that my challenge for Ito's position is inadverdantly causing rancour. Since Shin and Darkspace aren't in agreement with SSK's decision I won't battle Ito for his position. It isn't like I am allowed to win 3 times out of 100. I half to beat him 3 times in a row and losing once before winning 3 times would mean that I would have to start over against him completely. I won't try and use the rules to my advantage if it upsets the majority , I am not like Waluigi.
Click to expand...
Oh no.dont think of this as a Waluigi thing.This was simply a matter that needed to be cleared up weather you brung it up or not.I think of it more as a conversation to clear up the rules a bit.Because its kinda odd.You are in no way causing any problems at all.You'd probally be perfect for the last frontier brain.I just wish the rules would be more specific.so that were not all confused and having a conversation over it again.

silver%:well im on if you want a battle silver
 
actually, you did a good thing by opening up that can o' worms.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top