.:The Official Full Metal Alchemist Club:.

Samurai X said:
Who's the smexy girl in your avatar Greed?
Click to expand...

She is quite beautiful isn't she? (=

She's Romi Paku, she makes Edward Elric's voice in Japanese. <333 Oh yes yes I am so obsessed with her. ::licks lips::
 
Also, technically he is her actual kid, since he was cretaed from her bay's remains.
 
That can be technally possible... (I missed the first time they showed it at 12:00... I had to wait and hour to see it... stupid need for sleep...)
 
Actually, what you don't seem to comprehend is that Wrath IS her baby. As I watched the movie and read all the spoilers I found out Wrath is a homonculi, but not homonculi. Izumi is her mother. Not to be rude.
 
Well yeah, I know that because she protected him so much but I still see him as a homunculi, he even said it himself although I can't quote it because I don't know the exact words but it went something like this, "Some idiot tries to play God and he creates us." I'm pretty sure it was longer than that but that was his point. Also like in the episode on Saturday they have memories and whatever but they are still homunculi like Ed feels.
 
Ed doesn't realize that the Homculi are the people, however, they are incomplete. As Lust said, they are like Al.
 
Yup, I knew that and that's why they try to become human right? I think that because they are incomplete they are not real humans, they are the result of a failed transmutation and that is all. Ed says that what makes him and Al human are their souls. What I'm trying to say is that I do agree with you that they are the people but incomplete, but since they are incomplete they can not possibly have the soul of the human and therefore they are not human. That's just what I think, I'm probably not right though.....xD
 
^Just like Nina, but she couldnt talk. Failed transmutations. But I only have one question. Yeah, the Humonculi are evil, fine. They can talk, fine. But how can they talk when Nina couldnt? They were failed transutations too.
 
Sloth says that Tucker didn't have the strong will necessary to attach a soul, so it is another failed transmutation. This would mean that another homunculus was made at the time, dun dun dun. Although Sloth did say that it was a succesful human transmutation which I think was the physical appearance. This transmutation seems to be different though, I don't think a homunculus was made because Tucker thought he had actually attached the soul so he obviously didn't see The Gate or anything like that which means that a homunculus wasn't made. Also like Akio said, she was a Chimera.
 
No no no, there is no Nina-chimera homonculi! There is none, she was not a human, so there can't be a homonculi.
 
That's basically what I said at the end.

She was a human but all of Tucker's previous efforts didn't workwhich made her a chimera. She is a chimera now but she was a human at one point but she died, it's the same thing but Tucker just saved her physical form. Since she was a human a succesful human transmutation(which he did) and the attachment of her soul(which he didn't do) would have brought her back to life. What I'm trying to say is that there indeed could've been a homunculi if he would have come in contact with The Gate and if The Gate would have taken Nina but that didn't happen.
 
No actually there couldn't have been. Technically, the chimera would have needed memories.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top