what do you think is better pokemon yellow or emerald

[branchi]

i vote yellow.but still emerald is good.

 

[Timbjerr]

...

How are they even comparable? Objectively speaking, Emerald blows Yellow out of the water in every regard. The only thing Yellow has going for it is the abilty to acquire all three of its generation starters without reset/trading.

 

[valor555]

Yellow all the way i still find so much joy in replaying yellow but i couldnt be bother to go beat the elite four in emerald to get an legendaries

 

[thegeneticway]

Emerald by a land slide for me.

 

[Tudj]

Yellows a great game, but its emerald for me, the graphics kinda turn me off from playing yellow

 

[Cloche]

Emerald....
It has Gardevoir.

 

[Logiedan]

Yellow's an awesome game but I don't really get this voting poll because it's mostly biased. Emerald has excellent much,much better graphics than yellow.Emerald has newer features than Yellow and it includes with the first three generation's Pokemon. I vote for Emerald any way though the most enjoyable thing for me in Yellow was the E4 Champion Battle.

 

[xxxLatiasxxx]

I think Emerald is better than Yellow because Emerald has Latias and Latios in it.

 

[Kirbychuu]

Yellow is better imo. The newer releases can never beat the classics. They'll always hold a special place with me.

 

[MAizHxC]

I love Yellow...i didnt like the new generations too much :/

So yellow is my favorite :D

PS topic creator should add a poll

 

[Satoshi Ookami]

First generation is too old xD
Emerald for me

 

[RedViper1990]

Well...

I liked the release of Yellow more, cause the graphics of the pkmn were much better then the ones in Pokémon R/B and you could get a Pikachu with Surf, and at the time it was released, I still watched the anime ( yeah, I was just a little boy that time) I was thrilled that you could fight Jesse and James :P at the game, which I thought was very awesome back then.

I was kinda dissappointed with Emerald, it was basicly the same game as R/S for me, I expected more of it. (Rebattling Gym Leaders, other twist in the story around the 2 criminal teams, just wasn't enough for me.)

 

[Apostrophe]

Yellow is a game that is based off of both a game and a show that was based off the same game. I think Yellow version sacrificed a bit too much gameplay value in order to make it more like the show. A gym leader with only one Pokemon? Come on.

 

[~*!*~Tatsujin Gosuto~*!*~]

I don't see why you would compare yellow with Emerald, but it would of been nice if you threw in Crystal and maybe Platinum as well. But I have to go with Emerald because it's better,


:t354:TG

 

[The Bringer!]

I'd go with emerald cuz I prefer the genIII pokemon over the genI pokemon (Gasp! D=), also, any game that makes Koga have a party of venonats and a venomoth sucks.