weedle_mchairybug
Banned
- 2,688
- Posts
- 20
- Years
- Seen Aug 29, 2020
The thought of bringing in all the past companions is an intriguing one but it has just major and glaring issue: Reason to bring them there in the first place. Brock and Misty have excuses being that they're on vacation visiting but their goals aren't hampered by them doing so. Meaning the "Performer" Girls in May, Dawn and Serena would need a convincing hook or reason to show up there as opposed to Dawn during Unova. Iris has reason to show up as much as Misty does being a Dragon Master in training and wanting to test herself against Ash again. We can also throw in former rivals like Gary, Paul and Trip but like the companions, what reason is there for them to suddenly show up out of the blue and furthermore detracts from regional rivals in Kiawe(appears to be one now), Hau and Gladion.
Plus you also have May's Japanese VA issue to deal with if she was to make a return.
Well, to be fair, Gary at least could use the excuse of trying to investigate fossils in Alola to make an appearance (since he's dedicated to finding and reviving fossil Pokémon), and even Paul and Trip could at least use the set up league as an excuse to reappear (I mean, not like there's going to be much challengers in Alola as it is). But yeah, unless they conveniently have a Pokémon Contest going on in Alola, there's definitely no way May, Dawn, and Serena can make it through without making it look like they just interrupted their own goals (it was already bad enough that Dawn visited Unova despite its lack of contests. At least May had the interregional contest ribbon for the Wallace Cup as an excuse to technically interrupt her own goal by going to Sinnoh when she was supposed to be pursuing contests in Sinnoh). And that's not even taking into account how KAORI, May's VA, effectively pulled a Hillary Duff by becoming a singer over an actress. And yeah, Iris really needs a good opportunity to get in (especially after how she was gypped from an appearance in Kalos. Which is a shame, because at least she actually could go to Kalos without it interfering with her goal). She's the only person besides Misty and Brock that I wish to return at least once.