3rd Gen Which Johto Starter would you pick in Emerald?

[shanecdavis]

The Johto starters fail when it comes to the starters in the other regions, but I did pick Totodile the first time I completed the Pokedex because the Water is always the best of the three in every region.

 

[Pikachu™]

well, if I had the patience to get the whole of the Hoenn dex I would get Totodile hes a great water type! and looks so cute too

 

[¡No Hablo Inglés!]

I'd pick Totodile if I hadn't already traded for one, since it's my favourite starter from any generation and I have a tendency to choose Water types above any other type. I guess I'd probably pick Cyndaquil, mainly because I've never liked Chikorita.

 

[hothead]

Me and my mate finished thee game on the same day and i wanted todile and cyndiquill and he wanted cinderquill and todile so it was easy for us

 

[Lynnx]

I've never had the patience to complete a Pokedex, but I'd definately choose Chikorita. Meganium is one of my all-time favorite Pokemon and I almost never use Grass-types.

 

[SkyPioneer]

Chikorita needs some love.
Epic team support to be had.

 

[AuraAshley]

for me i would say cyndaquil. why? because he is my favorite Jonto starter

 

[The warden]

Cynderquil is my favorite but I picked Totodile because of a deal that I did with a friend. He got Chicorita another one of his friends got Cyinderquil and I got Totodile and then we traded eggs.

 

[Shaterpie]

When I had the chance I spent a lot of time making a decision, eventually I chose Totodile.

Ironically, I have all 3 now..

 

[RandomBlues]

Poor Chiko seems to be the least popular one at the moment(Maybe because it looks so much like a female?).
I think I'll try to get a female Cynda or Chiko, depending on what sounds good. Perferably Cynda, since if I am ever trading my pokemon over to games like DP or Plat(if it's possible), I am going to need a good pokemon. Or just take it to breed. But, I think Cynda.

 

[aaronburnsyou]

Well, I think you have your answer on who the least popular one is (Chikorita). I, perosnally, would choose Chikorita out of the three, not only because it's my favorite, but because it has the ability to heal itself without falling asleep, it has great survivability skills, and my team lacks a grass type (Breloom hardly counts).

 

[XxVuLpIxX]

yea, chikorita would be my choice too....=3

 

[PokemonMichael]

i have chikorita on my ruby because i traded it over.
im only 21 pokes away from another jhoto starter :3

 

[Zixtrent]

I would pick Cyndaquil. I have a Sceptile and Blastoise (traded from leaf green) so its about time i have a fire starter.

 

[CarniE]

I would Pick Chickorita Shes my 2nd favorite Starter.

 

[Steven15]

I usually pick totodile because they are cool

 

[Caelus]

Cyndaquil.
It's final evolution, Typhlosion, is possible the best of the three starters, not to mention it's awesome move pool which I find to be superior to that of the other two.
Cyndaquil is also the coolest, appearance-wise, and the same can apply to it's evolutions.

 

[Pokemonpro]

Mine is probably gonna be a cyndaquil cos its easy to raise and i got mine up to level 99 on my gold

 

[Andorale]

I like Chikorita. Bayleef and Meganium's fat though. x]

 

[The Post Count]

I'd pick totadile because its just soo cutee <3