4th Gen Which Version Do You Like Best?

[Neutral12]

The middle version of pokemon versions were always the best. Think things like Yellow and Crystal version.

 

[Unforgettable]

I enjoy Platinum. It's like an upgrade of the other two in a way? It incorporates both, and I just over all like the play of it.

 

[Zizi]

Platinum. I enjoyed Diamond but the storyline in Platinum was so much better and I liked the little random things they added in like the character Looker - just little things added in like that really improved my enjoyment of the game ^_^

 

[Sweet Jasmine]

In my opinion, I prefer Platinum since as what as stated above, It's the upgraded version of Diamond and Pearl Versions, and also you can caught both the three mascots, Dialga, Palkia and Giratina. :]

 

[CrazyEccentric]

I personally liked Pearl best... just because Pearl is my birthstone and Palkia is awesome.
I like Platinum second best because it seems to have a little more features in it and stuff.
I also got Pearl version first, so eh, its my favourite. -w-

 

[Bluerang1]

Platinum as it was more extended. Speaking of having for the longest, I need to look for my Diamond >_>

 

[MasterChaos45]

Its not really a competition seeing as how Platinum has all that D/P had and more.

 

[Ryanpoketrainer]

Platinum there is no competition D/P really are like the side storys and platinum is the main story

 

[sgtJARHEAD]

I only have Pearl so...GO PEARL!

 

[DeathOfBlades]

Platinum is by far my favorite. Why? Well you can catch both Palkia and Dialga. They have the Battle Frontier in 3-D which I loved in Emerald. The game is much more challenging than the other two. They made the sprites look more cool and interesting. They added more scenes along with a detective bothering you like that one fat dude in the Hawaiian T with Sun Glasses from Emerald. More forms for Rotom. A cool form for Giratina. You can re-battle Gym Leaders and trainers. So basically it just made the game much more fun.

 

[March]

Platinum just added allot of little things on top of the speed issues that plagued Diamond and Pearl, the Battle Frontier and Battle Ground really added to replay value which is what really won me over.

 

[RCMF13]

Platinum.

You don't need the national pokedex to get new evolutions pf magby, elekid, etc.

 

[Legendario]

diamond and pearl are completely the same (except the legendary palkia/dialga)

but platinum has a bigger storyline with 60 more pokemon in the sinnoh pokedex plus you can get dialga palkia and giratina
the detail is also quite a bit better.