Who is evil anyway?

[BH]

OK who is evil in Pokemon? Humans or Pokemon

Analis

Humans - Evil than Pokemon , although they are NO evil (Stupid YES) and powerless :laugh:

Pokemon - Great Powers , Deadly looks , assumed that they use Humans as Puppets :laugh:

So what do you think? who is the Devil of Pokemon World

 

[Natsuki]

Well, Pokemon only become "evil" because their trainers are essentially evil. As Ekans once said in the anime (The "Island of the Giant Pokemon" episode), "Pokemon do bad things because their masters are bad." So really, in my opinion, it is humans who are filled with malice and hate, and since Pokemon respond to their traner's feelings, they too will succumb to doing bad things.

~Kelsey

 

[Lily]

Neither. In the dimension of Pokemon, the rules fluctuate neatly between the order of both creature and human. Things are simply how they are. The Pokemon may be heavily influenced by their trainers' course of life, but the trainers merely follow what appears to be the standard way of things.

I vote the third one. ^_^

 

[BH]

As Ekans once said in the anime (The "Island of the Giant Pokemon" episode), "Pokemon do bad things because their masters are bad."

I think he (?) was joking us , since he (?) could KILL his master any time he wants , but maybe is duel to the love of his trainer he didn't attack? And BTW as i sayed , the anime made Team Rocket stupider than the game , i don't see any Team Rocket agents kill pokemon in the anime

And as i stated , Humans are NOT evil , but REEEEEEEEEALY stupid

 

[Trainer Rachel]

Well, Pokemon only become "evil" because their trainers are essentially evil. As Ekans once said in the anime (The "Island of the Giant Pokemon" episode), "Pokemon do bad things because their masters are bad." So really, in my opinion, it is humans who are filled with malice and hate, and since Pokemon respond to their traner's feelings, they too will succumb to doing bad things.

~Kelsey

I agree with this. It's the humans that can be evil, and then the Pokemon can follow their lead. BUT, however, some Pokemon may appear to be evil, and go on a rampage and kill others (doesn't Gyarados do this?) but they're only following their instincts, like animals. (I wouldn't call a bear "evil" because it killed someone - it doesn't think of morals and stuff like that).

Of course, some Pokemon (like Mewtwo) are very smart and human-like, and one would think that it can take into account morals and the like. But now thinking more on it, I don't think a Pokemon can really understand morals much at all, unless they're very smart and their trainers explain it to them.

So in conclusion, in regards to the First Movie, I wouldn't call Mewtwo evil. Why? If you know the background of his birth, including Ai (Amber) and everything, you'll see how he was deeply hurt, and couldn't really think of doing anything any other way, than by getting rid of humans. But then, when Ash gave his life to stop the fighting, Mewtwo had a change of heart, and was able to understand that what he was doing was wrong.

Hmmm... sounds familiar, huh? *cough*Jesus*cough*

-Trainer Rachel

 

[Vibes]

Well, I can go in to a whole thing about psychological things, but I choose tgo give the shorter answer, which pretty much agrees with what many of you have said:

It depends on how it is brought up. If there were tough times in the life of a human or Pokemon, then the creature may not come out very non-evil. There are some nice Pokemon who run around freely and do whatever they need, but there are the evil ones, who will hurt humans and excessively disobey trainers...There are some humans, that just have the desire to help, and they will help out. However, there are the poachers who do poor to the Pokemon and environment.

So, there is a balance between them, I think.

 

[~*!*~Tatsujin Gosuto~*!*~]

The Humans are because they are the ones that are telling the Pokemon what to do.

:t003:Dark Venusaur

 

[Egyptian Sphinx]

I agree with Dark Venusaur. Humans are evil since they do bad things in which their Pokemon follw their lead by slavery and commandment