Would an XY remake have been better?

[PoryKid575]

I remember a ton of speculation about a potential return to Kalos / an XY remake before the SV DLCs were announced due to the cloudy area on the map that roughly corresponded to Spain's border with France IRL. And while Z-A is technically a return, it seems like it's going to be a very different experience, with only Lumiose being explorable instead of the whole region. Do you think a more traditional remake, with the player going through the same plot / areas would've been a better approach?
--
I'm really conflicted about this. On one hand, X/Y are super nostalgic for me and they're old enough now to where they'd benefit from a new coat of paint. But on the other hand, I like how GF is trying something new instead of just retreading the same ground. Also, BDSP makes me skeptical that a traditional remake would actually be better than the originals.

 

[Nah]

I'm fine with us getting Legends ZA instead of an XY remake. It's probably not exactly going to be the Pokemon Z we were expecting back then, but it's still about as close as we're ever going to get to that. They will inevitably do an XY remake anyway, it's not like PLZA is killing the chance of that happening, it's just going to happen later is all.