Your favorite 1st stage starter

[enyce]

Mine from each generation

1st: Wartortle

2nd: Quilava

3rd: Marshtomp

Note:1st stage means its the second form of the pokemon

Example: Basic-Charmander---->1st Stage-Charmeleon---->2nd Stage-Charizard

Note: Multiple choces allowed

 

[Gary the Magic Fairy]

In order:
-Quilava
-Grovyle
-Charmeleon

 

[Jorah]

Its either Ivysaur or Wartortle...I can't choose! Oh, I'll just vote fo Wartortle because I have him in my party at the moment

 

[Axєl]

Charmeleon is my favorite out of those. Second is Beyleef.

x3

 

[JX Valentine]

Wartortle, no questions asked. For some reason, I don't like the others all that well.

Hence, I couldn't choose a favorite from Johto or Hoenn (although I can at least tolerate Marshtomp).

 

[Chesters_love]

its quilava because of my name,gold typhlosion!

 

[Barboach]

-Ivysaur
-Croconaw
-Marshtomp

Water starters seem to be my fav since they are helpful in every generation practically.

 

[Rioku_Zanketa]

meh...the first five you listed.....not much others catch my eye.....

 

[[Technya]]

Quilavs and Grovyle have always been my favorites but Quilava more than Grovyle.

 

[Natsuki]

Charmeleon for sure. X3 I remember waaaaaay back in the old days when I used to collect the Pokemon cards, I practically worshiped my Charmeleon card. XD Plus it's like a dragon/lizard type deal, it's so cool! :3

~Kelsey

 

[WHALESDUDE]

I like all teh fire guys just because I think they look the coolest... plus, cindaquil, charmander, and torchic are so cute ^_^

 

[Ai]

1. charmeleon
2. quilava
3. croconaw

fire rocks :) and the feral aligator rocks too!

 

[WHALESDUDE]

Yeah, feraligator was really sweet. I remember playing the origional japaneese version like a year before it came on Game boy on my pc via a floppy disk! I chose the water started and ended up with this huge blue guy. It was awesome ^_^

 

[Astinus]

Fwee for Quilava. I love the nasally voice this critter has in the dub. Plus, it's the cutest in my eyes out of all the choices.

 

[Kalylia]

I love Quilava and Bayleef. They are just adorable, and much more cuddly than most of the starters. Bayleef isn't exactly the strongest Pokemon, but Quilava definatley has potential!

 

[Chiru]

Wartortle in first place, followed by Croconaw.

 

[Garouga! Bare Your Fangs!]

-Ivysaur
-Marshtomp
-Bayleef

Bayleef is at the bottom due to lack of Grass attacks.

 

[The Fallen]

Mine was Charmeleon. I remember Charizard being so popular that when the games came out everyone had to have him.

 

[Aegis]

Mine is Crocanaw then Combusken. I like there evolved forms the best ^^

 

[Skitty101]

1. Combuskin

2. Bayleef

3. Quilava

I have a Combusken in Emerald and I'm not gonna evolve it. I like it better as Combusken. :)

Bayleef is pretty cool! I like how it won against Houndoom in the Silver conference.

Quilava is awesome! Why better the the 2nd stage! No offence.