Map Rating/Review Thread

[.Iramet]

NAME-dunno yet
GAME-fire red
COMMENTS-thanks to pho for the rombase

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Ok...no one looks at the page before and the only reply I got was "It's awesome!" so...here it is again...
First floor of a mountain...

And...another one. A peninsula.

Yeah, so...just rate them please!

 

[Chimchar 9]

Ok...no one looks at the page before and the only reply I got was "It's awesome!" so...here it is again...
First floor of a mountain...

And...another one. A peninsula.

Yeah, so...just rate them please!

the shape of the cave *i love it* its really good but i think you should put a bit more rocks i give it 10/10 well done

the second map a bit small and i love them little cliffs and its near a beach whoo i give it 8/10
them maps are really good

 

[Neti]

remember this map i posted on the last site?

Spoiler:

Ive edited the Tileset a bit and adjusted thee map, ratings plz:

This time i made the mapshot without events, just sayin this cause some people might wonder where all the trainers went^^
the new grass and trees are made by PHO, credit goes to them
btw im currently editing that crater thing cause i find it ugly^^ pls rate the map without it, cause otherwise i have ti upload the new image again

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

hey Neti, the new maps great! However can you take a few of the small rocks? There still are too much in one place! (Bottom Right Corner!) The grass fits in and it is a great desert route that blends everything within together!

Rating: 9.9/10

Anyway, can anyone rate my map? Its already been posted for a hack that I'm helping on, but can it be improved?

Name: (Name Here) Forest

Description: A forest.

Comment: Can anything be improved? Can you rate it too please?

 

[Mitchman]

COMMENT: the lab-like building is a bit thin, is it not?
RATINGS: 9/10
REASON: I truly love it.
SUGGESTION: The lab. Eek... >.<

Jagold i would complain to baro bout that. Its his lab if i remember

 

[Neti]

hey Neti, the new maps great! However can you take a few of the small rocks? There still are too much in one place! (Bottom Right Corner!) The grass fits in and it is a great desert route that blends everything within together!

Rating: 9.9/10

The many rocks are supposed to be all at one spot, theyre blocking the entrance to crossbone graveyard. that entrance is a bit like a canyon and so there are many rocks

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Thank you for clearing that up Neti. I still stand by my statement of too many rocks, but I now know why that is. Can anyone rate my map still?

Name: (Name Here) Forest

Description: A forest

Comments: Can you rate it please?

 

[MudMast]

please don't attach the image, put it in image tags.

Thank you for clearing that up Neti. I still stand by my statement of too many rocks, but I now know why that is. Can anyone rate my map still?

Name: (Name Here) Forest

Description: A forest

Comments: Can you rate it please?

Spoiler:

like that.
oops, 7/10 - EDIT

anyway, its actually, quite good.
I like how it bends round, forcing you to follow it, but there are a few things I suggest you do.

I suggest you change how it is too square, how the trees are at a right angle, doesn't look real.
Also, with the grass, don't make it as a rectangular shape, like in the middle.
3: Not all of the space has to be filled, klike in the bottom right corner, leave some blank grass tiles.
Last: Too many signposts! Too many, and too many cramped up together. Try moving some around the map, and maybe remove a few.

 

[1215912159]

Map Name: Rotel Town.

Map Game: FireRed.

Comments: Just Rate it. Thanks. ^^

Mapshot:

um...im not a pro at mapping but...this map looks sort of...blank.

a lot of it is square which never makes a good map. those trees are at a perfect / so its not a good set up. a sugestion from me would be to take out the bottom three trees, move the mart to behind the pokecenter (Cuz that REALLY looks blank) and put up a big building or sky scraper just to give it a little more...city look.

around...6.5/10 its too blank!

 

[.Iramet]

hey I give oshers map a 6 it is waay to square

 

[cooley]

Name of Map: Route 24

From: Pokemon FireRed :D

Screenie:

Spoiler:

Comments:
Part of my hack, I just finished it today, and I have to say...I am proud of it!
Please rate, I'll accept ratings from 10 or higher! :P

P.S. I made those GSC headbutt trees myself ;)
P.S.S. I did not use that guys RomBase, I only took some tree and path tiles...
​

 

[+Sneasel™]

Map Name: Route 24

From: Pokemon FireRed :D

Screenie:

Spoiler:

Comments:
Part of my hack, I just finished it today, and I have to say...I am proud of it!
Please rate, I'll accept ratings from 10 or higher! :P
​

Great map!
I love the tiles and palletes, the trees look great! The placement of them rocks too! I like the way the mountain starts off rocky, and then turns to grass, its cool :)
I give it a 10/10, there is honestly nothing wrong with it and it looks great!

 

[WindBlows]

Name of Map: Route 24

From: Pokemon FireRed :D

Screenie:

Spoiler:

Comments:
Part of my hack, I just finished it today, and I have to say...I am proud of it!
Please rate, I'll accept ratings from 10 or higher! :P

P.S. I made those GSC headbutt trees myself ;)
P.S.S. I did not use that guys RomBase, I only took some tree and path tiles...
​

Hey cooley!
Lovely map! i love the tiles and also the palettes.
The unique thing I see wrong with it is about the rocy path after you climb the stairs. it should be other tile unless you make a grass-rock connection. :P
By the way, you should also insert some grass (pokémon) to it.
Anyways, I rate it 9/10!

 

[Luck]

No map ratings for now.
alright, i have found a new tree tile that i loved.
Map name:Skull woods
Game:Firered
comments: I named it skull woods because to me, it looked like the trees resembled skulls.

Spoiler:

Credits To Alistair and PHO for the trees

 

[Aquila]

No map ratings for now.
alright, i have found a new tree tile that i loved.
Map name:Skull woods
Game:Firered
comments: I named it skull woods because to me, it looked like the trees resembled skulls.

Spoiler:

Credits To Alistair and PHO for the trees

Rating: 7/10
Reason: I get the feel that the mountains don't belong in there. And the trees on the top of your map is in a line and pretty square compared to the other places..

 

[Luck]

Rating: 7/10
Reason: I get the feel that the mountains don't belong in there. And the trees on the top of your map is in a line and pretty square compared to the other places..

Yeah, i was trying to make it better, but the connections would screw up.
and i just hate maps without rocky tiles in them.
i also had the feeling that it was too empty to be a forest.

 

[.Iramet]

I give cooleys map a 10 10

 

[Mr.Fury]

Name: ?
Rom: Firered
Its the starting town.
Comments:
I made half of it at like 3 in the morning and woke up and finished it.
Its like my fifth map.

 

[Nina]

Map Name: ???

Map Game: FireRed

Comments:
I literally started mapping last night. LOL. So I don't have any custom tile sets for the fact that it wasn't until this morning I learned how to edit them to try to fix a problem. (Which wasn't fixed, hah.)
This town is ment to be very nature 'secret stuck in the woods' town even if it is big. Thus there is not defined routes out of the town. The second one is only a square big, but I actually havn't made the route for there yet.

Mapshot:
:o Clicky