Map Rating/Review Thread

[Soul.//Silver]

Map Name: Route ?
Map Game: RPG Maker XP
Comments: I've made a map, a big map and I spent a lot of time into it. Hope you like it, because in another forum, it was criticized.



In a link, because it is a huge map.

On-Topic:
1 Word, WOW. 10/10, perfect map and I don't see anything wrong with it (ignore those bad comments, I think it is excellent).

Off-Topic:
Oh and the game development really should have its own map rating thread to prevent people mistakenly placing their maps in this thread.

 

[Surf]

On-Topic:
1 Word, WOW. 10/10, perfect map and I don't see anything wrong with it (ignore those bad comments, I think it is excellent).

Off-Topic:
Oh and the game development really should have its own map rating thread to prevent people mistakenly placing their maps in this thread.

Well then make one, silly.

[ontopic] That map is amazing Amazing, very detailed and the feature that I like most is the Playability.
Great job!

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

Map Name: ??
Rom: Fire Red(German)
Credits: Kyledove, wesleyfg, Hackrex
Comments: It was very hard to create this map... Maybe its the hardest map i ever made(sorry for bad english^^)

View attachment 45969

 

[destinedjagold]

Map Name: ??
Rom: Fire Red(German)
Credits: Kyledove, wesleyfg, Hackrex
Comments: It was very hard to create this map... Maybe its the hardest map i ever made(sorry for bad english^^)

View attachment 45969

Comment: It looks really nice for a route. The complexity and the naturality is nice.
Rating: 8/10
Suggestion: nothing, I guess...

 

[Ray Maverick]

I have to agree with DJG,the map is really cool.
rating: 9/10

i think it's ok,you don't need to add anything.

 

[NatureKeeper]

Map Name: ??
Rom: Fire Red(German)
Credits: Kyledove, wesleyfg, Hackrex
Comments: It was very hard to create this map... Maybe its the hardest map i ever made(sorry for bad english^^)

View attachment 45969

Rating: 9.5/10
Reason: I believe this map is one of a kind
Comments: Are you sure this is FireRed? It kinda reminds me of Platinum's Graphics Rendering, Seriously, Great Job~

~NatureKeeper

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Oksies.

You guys gonna rate a Fire Emblem map? Only do so if you've played FE. >_> I don't want people rating me down for tile errors when there aren't any. The tiles don't match.

Oi, Disturbed, give me a ten because mapping in Mappy is much harder than in A-map.

 

[Eletj]

Oksies.

You guys gonna rate a Fire Emblem map? Only do so if you've played FE. >_> I don't want people rating me down for tile errors when there aren't any. The tiles don't match.

Oi, Disturbed, give me a ten because mapping in Mappy is much harder than in A-map.

Gotta love FE~

Rating: 9/10
Comment: I think I can see one Map Error, but hey, you can barely notice it. Very cool indeed.
Suggestion: Could I maybe see your enemy placements?

 

[Dratii]

Nice, that is a well done map, although the mountains need a little work even though they are so dam hard and the fort in the mountain is a bit strange. Also the bushes up the top are double bushes I think they have another bush to connect with them
7.8/10

Gotta love FE~

Rating: 9/10
Comment: I think I can see one Map Error, but hey, you can barely notice it. Very cool indeed.
Suggestion: Could I maybe see your enemy placements?

It is a lot harder to show enemy placements in FE than Pokemon, you need to play it in the game and take screenshots then assemble them into the map shape.

 

[Superjub]

So, I decided to give another go at hacking FireRed and here is my first city:

 

[DARKSHADE]

So, I decided to give another go at hacking FireRed and here is my first city:

well, its ok,but i dont like the pallette and i think the map is maybe "too symetrical" and theres a tile error

pallette:3/10
tiles; (havent changed so i cant rate)
overall: 5/10

sorry for the bad score :( but i can help you improve if you want?

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

So, I decided to give another go at hacking FireRed and here is my first city:

Right then, lets see. There are a few errors, like the Pond's bottom 2 corners, and a bit on the river when near the bridges. Also, it seems too square and like D-SHADE said, symmetrical. Too much free space, the path is too thick at some places for my liking. I like the flower's pallette though, but try making the town less square, and more natural looking.

I give this a 5/10, I'm too kind sometimes.

 

[Jordy San]

Right then, lets see. There are a few errors, like the Pond's bottom 2 corners, and a bit on the river when near the bridges. Also, it seems too square and like D-SHADE said, symmetrical. Too much free space, the path is too thick at some places for my liking. I like the flower's pallette though, but try making the town less square, and more natural looking.

I give this a 5/10, I'm too kind sometimes.

And if you look at the small trees around the flowewr paradise, you see one is dfferent.
And if you compare teh different one to the normal ones, I should replace them with the different ones :)

So try to use the dvise given and I know you can do much better ;)

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Gotta love FE~
Rating: 9/10
Comment: I think I can see one Map Error, but hey, you can barely notice it. Very cool indeed.
Suggestion: Could I maybe see your enemy placements?

It is a lot harder to show enemy placements in FE than Pokemon, you need to play it in the game and take screenshots then assemble them into the map shape.

Exactly what I was going to say. I normally do enemies as a spur of the moment thing when writing the coding.

Oh, and who shows their events when mapping in Pokemon? It spoils it, doesn't it?

Yeah, I realised there are a couple of tile errors, mostly involving the trees and fort on top (There's a better tile. >.<)

Dratii, they use forts in mountains in FE7... :\

 

[destinedjagold]

Oksies.

You guys gonna rate a Fire Emblem map? Only do so if you've played FE. >_> I don't want people rating me down for tile errors when there aren't any. The tiles don't match.

Spoiler:

Oi, Disturbed, give me a ten because mapping in Mappy is much harder than in A-map.

COMMENT: That map looks cute. <3
RATING: 8/10
SUGGESTION: I don't have FE so I can't really suggest anything... :\ :P :D

So, I decided to give another go at hacking FireRed and here is my first city:

Spoiler:

COMMENT: It's too square...
RATING: 3/10
SUGGESTION: The map's too square. Everything's too aligned and a lot of useless spaces... Try and read some mapping tutorial located in the Documents and Tutorials and read some mapping tutorial there.

 

[hinsburg]

Messed around in Gold Map a bit and came up with this redesign of New Bark Town. Nothing too special.

Map Name: White Town
Map Game: Pokemon Gold Hack Of Awesomeness

I might try tile editing later and see what I can come up with. (I just learned that the word editing only has one t. Fun.)

 

[Crimson Stardust]

Map

I have nothing to do so i created this map...there maybe have errors but overall...haha Look at it...
View attachment 46030

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Another map, Chapter 4's map. It's in the plains, and it's totally slightly based upon the two plains maps in FE6's B Route.

 

[Dratii]

Here is one of my FE maps

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

-Is angry-

Why is your map so much better-looking than mine? >:[

It's very impressive. The mountains are pretty good, just the top tile looks too bright and they are some problems in the way the split moves. Or, well, there's something that looks better.

9/10