It would be nice to reach a majority, considering it's not a great idea to leave that decision solely to one person, whether they're maf or not (which, in this case, they very well could be).
At the same time, I haven't seen anything overly compelling from anyone just yet, so one person's shot in the dark is no worse than a group shot in the dark. So long as that one person isn't a Witch.
So
There's almost zero chance we'll reach a majority today, but (unless the judge manages to hit a Witch today, by some miracle) we should come up with something to back for tomorrow. Controlled chaos might still be chaos, but at least it's easier to sift through.