Pokestick good times.

We were all newbies once right? I guess that's partly why I left.

Hello, I would like to say sorry for every vm I have ever given you. I've always sucked at grammar and spelling.

Just...question, first. Which MC design do you like the most?

What happened to Signature-chan ;_;

HOT

Hot, definitely. She looks great, I'd even say that this might be my favorite incarnation of her, though I think the hat could use a little less bag. Not all the bag, but I just realized, looking back, that there's been something of a bag evolution going on with it.

-That's not a bad thing, but I feel like it could do with just slightly less bag. It could be because of the shift in color that I think this, though, since I was so used to it being black it might just feel a bit off because of the drastic shift.

;D

Yeah. You took the mature pretty design, which I liked a lot.

Looking good, but I can't help but be bothered by the fact that her legs are freakishly long. Rival-me-san looks more normal.

I do like the new design, it really works, but...I do have to wonder about that "Taken off" design. It feels like something's missing. And I know that makes sense when something that could be considered the focal point of the character, or at least something that you almost identify with their character, is missing, but here it seems like, and I don't want this to sound bad, but it looks kind of like she's lacking.

This isn't necessarily a bad thing, as I think that could easily be compensated for with a show of personality by the character, but I'd say her design inherently benefits from having it on. If I had to put this another way, I'd say that it probably comes from there not really being too much to her mid-lower body.

...Actually, this all does seem harsh, and I don't want it to seem that way because I really do like her design, but this is what popped up.

swedish roulette

Upper middle right reminds me of Alice. I like it.

Upper left is swag.

Middle left with the Poliwrath is really cute.

Bottom two are pretty.

I really like a few of those lol.

True.

What immediately jumps out to me is a brown or a dark green. Or maybe a brownish-orange (or just a darker orange). I think these could potentially compliment her color scheme pretty well.

Those are the colors I'd suggest, anyway. Orange, in particular, contrasts with the rival's blue, and it is similar enough to her hair color that it's not distractingly standout-ish nor is it too homogenized- well, theoretically. I don't actually know, considering this is just theory. But a brown would work for similar reasons.

Also, I looked at the comments you and macho threw around.

Keep the beret tbh, it's part of her character. As for the black void that is currently her beret, maybe dark green or brown could work?

As for rival-me-san, I pretty much agree with macho. Reminds me of Yowapeda. Like she's a hobbyist biker or something.

that is me with shorter hair plus beauty mark

I'm a fan of the rival's design. Glad you went with a brighter bluetealblue, too, because it really works well with the black (and white). Me like.

As for MC, there's something that feels...off. And who knows, maybe it's just because the colors are solid in this picture, but the black is very...consuming. As in, I look into her beret and I feel as if I must question my existence. But looking at the previous picture, the lighter shade of black looks pretty comfortable.

Could just be me, though. I've been looking at this picture for a while trying to compose my thoughts, so it could be that.

I now know why you wanted me to get to Second Season asap. Me liking Nadeko a lot in S1 had a lot to do with it, I see. :p

S2 really did go cray-cray. But I liked what I saw. I couldn't believe what was happening for a good part of it but I still really, really liked whatever I saw. It was tragic, though. The fact that Araragi was told to not meet her from then onwards and all...

Not to forget, Kaiki! I've still got some of the series yet to watch so I don't even know if the guy survives or not. I hope he does. I don't really dislike him all that much now. After Koimonogatari, I, in fact, like him. :p

Someone's been busy.

iluvher. Though I'd say the bottom right sketch reminds me more of Ryuko.