Map Rating/Review Thread

Ray Marverick said:

This map has playability zero. if you have the HM surf, you can go wherever you want (west - east).
However, you're improving and thats good. Try changing the paths, and the tree placement in front of the PC( and da fence) :P

And don't put too many rocks in a village like this...

Click to expand...

The map is playable.

I rate it 10/10. I see nothing wrong with it.

Map Name: World Map (Don't have a region name yet)
Base ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokemon Rising Sun
Comments: No comments, really. This is my 2nd world map, so I would like feedback.

Map:

A new map of mine. Look at it - Rate it ._.

Map Game: FireRed (GER)
Map Name: uuh... None?
Comments: None²?
Credits:
-Kyledove
-Newtiteuf
-Neoks
-Wesley FG
-C.N.C
-rhevarhe_duh

Mapshot:


~MOP

//edit: Yeah! 100th post :D

MASTEROFPUPPETS93 said:

A new map of mine. Look at it - Rate it ._.

Map Game: FireRed (GER)
Map Name: uuh... None?
Comments: None²?
Credits:
-Kyledove
-Newtiteuf
-Neoks
-Wesley FG
-C.N.C
-rhevarhe_duh

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

~MOP

//edit: Yeah! 100th post :D

Click to expand...

This looks almost exactly like the tiles and palettes I've been inserting into my hack actually. xD

I love how you made the map look beautiful and natural, yet you gave the player plenty of room to move around. Except for the right side of the map with the one tile wide stairs and the area with the ledges, this map has very good playability. I also found a place the player would most likely miss when playing through that could hold a hidden item so good job on that.

9/10

this is map of ma new region Corra .. map inspired by HG/SS
tell me your opinions please :)

9/10 it looks rele good but the blue-ish green kinda looks like water so it looks like the land was flouded

JohnnyRoll said:

this is map of ma new region Corra .. map inspired by HG/SS
tell me your opinions please :)

Spoiler:

... - Bus Road
Brown Road - Subway

Click to expand...

Interesting. Water is laid out in layers going from bright to dark with land being next to the bright....good...More concentration of trees is need. Put another layer on the mountains, and make the darker, thinner one, near-land, thicker. Looks very nice.
8/10, 10/10 if you fix what I said.

I was thinking about trees concetration too .. :laugh:
thank you for your advice :) I tried to make it little more perfect ..and ta-da :D

JohnnyRoll said:

I was thinking about trees concetration too .. :laugh:
thank you for your advice :) I tried to make it little more perfect ..and ta-da :D

Spoiler:

Click to expand...

You would not believe how much better that looks. There's still just one thing that bothers me. The main color of the land. The sea-green for the grassy areas. Make it a bit less bluish.
Green it up just a tad bit, to differentiate it from the sea a bit better.

9.9/10, 10/10 if you green up the land.

here it is :D I just want 10/10 from you xD



Sry guys for too much posting :)

JohnnyRoll said:

here it is :D I just want 10/10 from you xD

Spoiler:

Sry guys for too much posting :)

Click to expand...

Heres a 10/10 from me too...

This is Amazing...The Colors and trees are great...And the pathways are well organized...Nice Job on this...;)

JohnnyRoll said:

here it is :D I just want 10/10 from you xD

Spoiler:

Sry guys for too much posting :)

Click to expand...

Wowie!! An amazing world map!! I give a 10/10!!

JohnnyRoll said:

here it is :D I just want 10/10 from you xD

Spoiler:

Sry guys for too much posting :)

Click to expand...

Well, I Don't Know Much, But That Looks Pretty Awesome!
I Like How You Have All The Vibrant Colors!
9/10

Here is the new Pinehurst town for Pokemon Emerald Thunder which is a hack of FR. Credits to Kyledove, Zeikku (pounder_Lili now, i think?) and alistair.

Archon said:

Here is the new Pinehurst town for Pokemon Emerald Thunder which is a hack of FR. Credits to Kyledove, Zeikku (pounder_Lili now, i think?) and alistair.

Spoiler:

Click to expand...

7/10 there is no duration between grass and rock and its a lil empty

narutoactor said:

7/10 there is no duration between grass and rock and its a lil empty

Click to expand...

idk what you mean by duration... do mean separation?

Anyways, I fixed it up a bit...

Archon said:

idk what you mean by duration... do mean separation?

Anyways, I fixed it up a bit...

Spoiler:

Click to expand...

Ill give it a 7/10 its too spacey and did you use a rom base? if you did which one?

Map Name: Route 01

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: This is the first map I made two weeks ago. Please rate it out of 10, and gimme some information bout what should be better and stuff... and if you noticed some errors.

Mapshot:

0d' said:

Map Name: Route 01

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: This is the first map I made two weeks ago. Please rate it out of 10, and gimme some information bout what should be better and stuff... and if you noticed some errors.

Mapshot:

Click to expand...

8.5/10 theres a empty montane area and the grass lands a little empty try adding some flowers and some more trees

Map Name: Antona Road (The equivalent of the first route)

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: First off, I know my grass placement sucks here. I'm not satisfied with it, but I can't get it to look good, no matter where I put it. To the east, there is a second route that leads to a city, the starting town is directly North of this route, and to the West there is a town which is not meant to be reached until later in the game (hence the rock smash rocks blocking the cave enterance).

Mapshot: (Click for a full-size view)