Map Rating/Review Thread

[Pokepal17]

Name:Torsei Side
From:Fire Red
Tiles:Wesley Fg & Kyledove & My own tiles
Rombase:Allen
Info:My improved map
Rate it guys

Spoiler:

This is a very nice map. I like the usage of tiles and the placement of tress. However I see a block editing error. Also, will this be connected to some routes because if it isn't you will encounter a large number of border errors.

But anyways, overall it's a very good map and very playable.

Improvements - block edit to fix some errors.

Rating - 8.8/10

 

[Makorin]

Map Name: Koujou City
Map Game: BPRE Fire Red (U)
Comments: This is the 3rd Town/City in my hack, Magma Version
You have just gotten out of a cave before you come from the North!
The building next to the PC is the Pokemon Fan Club
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[NarutoActor]

Map Name: Koujou City
Map Game: BPRE Fire Red (U)
Comments: This is the 3rd Town/City in my hack, Magma Version
You have just gotten out of a cave before you come from the North!
The building next to the PC is the Pokemon Fan Club
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

pretty good 8/10 the routes are all over the place and some tile errors and the fan club has no distinct difference from one of the other bildings

 

[Kyouya]

Map Name: golug town

Map Game: emerald

Comments: i got the patch for firered then i made a pathc of that for emerald

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Lightning Sage™]

Map Name: golug town

Map Game: emerald

Comments: i got the patch for firered then i made a pathc of that for emerald

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Rateing: 3/10
Comments:
WEll when i first saw this map i said these horible pallets look disgusting but then i looked to the rest of the map and said the mapping makes this map look 2xworse than it already is. For starters that bush on the left is usless and unessicary.. Fill the map up more with tress and not as much rocks... And flowers dont grow liek that in random places they grow in bunches. The pathway is way to square. SO overall read some tuts and practice more and youl eventually get better but remember to try and be more natural

 

[Neo-Wolf]

Map Name: golug town

Map Game: emerald

Comments: i got the patch for firered then i made a pathc of that for emerald

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Rating - 2.5 / 10
Comments - Horrible Pallets and some tile errors .

 

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Map Name: golug town

Map Game: emerald

Comments: i got the patch for firered then i made a pathc of that for emerald

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Could use a bit of work... so long as the characters have nice pallets I am sure this pallet would be fine.
And it could use a bit of de-squaring... 4/7

Name:Torsei Side
From:Fire Red
Tiles:Wesley Fg & Kyledove & My own tiles
Rombase:Allen
Info:My improved map
Rate it guys

Spoiler:

This map is amazing!
The only flaw I see is the uniform locations of the rocks in the water.
I love the water's shape, as well as teh organization of your paths.
Keep it up!
8.5/10

 

[Darthatron]

Map Name: Route 003
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I opened an old ROM in Advance Map and started doing stuff. And that person/pokemon/tree is the place you learn cut, or something.
Map Shot:

Spoiler:

 

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Map Name: Route 003
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I opened an old ROM in Advance Map and started doing stuff. And that person/pokemon/tree is the place you learn cut, or something.
Map Shot:

Spoiler:

Looks great... and can you say GRASS?
I love your mapping style, and I gotta say, 9.5/10
Tryto localize your flowers, flowers tend to grow in bunches.
PS
My sig still > your sig
lol

 

[Crimson Stardust]

Name:Smallwood Village
From:Fire Red
Rombase:Allen
Credit:Wesley Fg & Kyledove
Info: This will the map for the starter town in my hack{but this is not where the hero lives}

Rate it guys..

Spoiler:

 

[Darthatron]

Map Name: Not Available
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I guess this would be the last town or something, since the League is located here. This should probably be two maps, but I imagined that the screen would pan across to the town from that dirt patch on the top of the mountain, and that would need to be map, I think.
Map Shot: (MASSIVE IMAGE)

Spoiler:

 

[Pokepal17]

Map Name: Not Available
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I guess this would be the last town or something, since the League is located here. This should probably be two maps, but I imagined that the screen would pan across to the town from that dirt patch on the top of the mountain, and that would need to be map, I think.
Map Shot: (MASSIVE IMAGE)

Spoiler:

Awesome map, I love te tree and house placement. 9.4/10

 

[Kyouya]

Map Name: Route 135
Map Game: emerald
Rombase:the blob of blob's d/p base
Comments:Well i decided to make a map to test out tiles came out good to me
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Map Name: Not Available
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I guess this would be the last town or something, since the League is located here. This should probably be two maps, but I imagined that the screen would pan across to the town from that dirt patch on the top of the mountain, and that would need to be map, I think.
Map Shot: (MASSIVE IMAGE)

Spoiler:

I would have expected better out of you.
The pallets may be pretty but you have to fix the shape of the cliffs.
WAAAY too straight.
The paths in the town are good, but again, the flowers, bunch them up in groups of 3's or 4's...
7/10

 

[sasquatchd00d]

I'm digging out some old maps to post here. I think some of them I already posted before, but some might be new to you guys.

Map Name: Route
Base ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: It was Pokémon Shian by Goodies/Alice.
Comments: I'm aware of the border error near the top right of the map. Also the border error near the bottom center.

Map:

Spoiler:

Map Name: Route 134 and Route 134 Underwater
Base ROM: Ruby AXVE
Hack: None.
Comments: This one isn't too old, but I'm posting it again to see some more rates on it. Also, there's obviously border errors that I haven't addressed because this isn't in a hack.

Maps:

Spoiler:

Map Name: Snowy City
Base Rom: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: None.
Comments: I don't really like this one that much. I'm kind of disappointed with the layout of the city. No border errors on this one. ^_^

Map:

Spoiler:

 

[Crimson Stardust]

I'm digging out some old maps to post here. I think some of them I already posted before, but some might be new to you guys.

Map Name: Route
Base ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: It was Pokémon Shian by Goodies/Alice.
Comments: I'm aware of the border error near the top right of the map. Also the border error near the bottom center.

Map:

Spoiler:

I like how you organise the map.I like the pallete use{even though this is not a pallete rating}i like how you mix the big trees and with the small trees..
I give this 10/10

Map Name: Route 134 and Route 134 Underwater
Base ROM: Ruby AXVE
Hack: None.
Comments: This one isn't too old, but I'm posting it again to see some more rates on it. Also, there's obviously border errors that I haven't addressed because this isn't in a hack.

Maps:

Spoiler:

Firstly,this is a cool map.Both the map..but there is the tile error at the first one which is not the underwater one.It is at the bottom right hand corner
for the underwater,i like them.Its quite cool
for the first:9/10
underwater:9.5/10

Map Name: Snowy City
Base Rom: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: None.
Comments: I don't really like this one that much. I'm kind of disappointed with the layout of the city. No border errors on this one. ^_^

Map:

Spoiler:

Nothing to say about this map.Its flawless..{i think}
Snow City:10/10

 

[Luck]

I'm digging out some old maps to post here. I think some of them I already posted before, but some might be new to you guys.

Map Name: Route
Base ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: It was Pokémon Shian by Goodies/Alice.
Comments: I'm aware of the border error near the top right of the map. Also the border error near the bottom center.

Map:

Spoiler:

Sorry, but I can only rate 1 map. I will rate the first one, since it is the easiest to talk about(rating maps at 5:00 in the morning isn't exactly perfect timing for rating maps.)

Alrighty, here we go.
I'll get this out of my system. The diagonal mountain tiles are wrong. Hopefully you can see it because it just immediately jumps from mountain tile to grass, not a single transition. I will affect the rating because of it, but that is the only tile in this map I will put on the rating.
The mountains look neat, but I think you just put in a few too many rocks, and too close to each other. The grass is okay I guess, but you can actually go through the whole area by entering only one encounter(unless you put the encounter rate relatively high.) It is also devoid of any creativity, since nothing grows in between the tall grass, except for more tall grass.
I'm not a fan of the flowers in patches(I place them randomly and get no points added or subtracted from the score.) The trees are really linear, but get "overgrown" later. I know that means that civilization is clearly to the left, but I just don't like when one part of a map is completely opposite of how another map is supposed to be. Despite all of these, I think this is a great map that you have made, and it's pretty high quality, although I should expect that from you. I would give it a 7.5/10.

Edit: I'll rate the other maps when I can get the time(and if you want), but probably not here.

 

[Crimson Stardust]

Smallwood

Name:Smallwood Village
From:Fire Red
Credits:Wesley Fg & Kyledove Tiles & Allen help
Info:Since this is not rated,here it is...it is the first village for my hack

Spoiler:

 

[NarutoActor]

Name:Smallwood Village
From:Fire Red
Credits:Wesley Fg & Kyledove Tiles & Allen help
Info:Since this is not rated,here it is...it is the first village for my hack

Spoiler:

7.5/10 routes are a to straight and trees are blocky

 

[Samike360]

Name:Smallwood Village
From:Fire Red
Credits:Wesley Fg & Kyledove Tiles & Allen help
Info:Since this is not rated,here it is...it is the first village for my hack

Spoiler:

8/10. I like this map, the paths are pretty good but you could try to connect them a little more. Also, at the bottom left of the houses (next to the door) there is a tile error, you need to pout the left side of the black outline like on the other side of the houses.