Worst Plot Twists

there were never any creatures terrorizing the woods. It was really just the people who lived in the village putting on monster costumes to scare everyone into believing something was out there, when there wasn't. It was a conspiracy to keep generations of people from ever leaving their community. There was never any real danger the whole time. Not only was this pretty anticlimactic, but I think it's a bit implausible. The costumes were stashed in carelessly-easy-to-discover places like right there in the garden shed, and under the floorboard of your houses. C'mon y'all.

The characters are living in a rural farm community that we we're supposed to think is still somewhere in the 19th century at the beginning of the story, when it was all really happening right now. But you could only sustain this illusion for the people living there for so long. Someone is going to see an airplane fly overhead sometimes. Even an Amish community is not living in a state where their fellowship is completely oblivious to the existence of the world outside, in fact often they cooperate frequently with it actually for commerce or to help the local authorities, they're just choosing to live a simple life and reduce outside influences as much as they can. You could maybe pull a plot twist like this off in a post apocalyptic earth where the world population has been reduced, therefore fewer people to potentially come into contact with at any given moment. Scifi shows like the Twilight Zone and The Outer Limits have had episodes with similar themes, but I'm not buying this in the context the The Village takes place in. Sorry, try again.