• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Which Pokémon Masters protagonist do you like most? Let us know by casting a vote in our Masters favorite protagonist poll here!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

[Hack of the Year] Results - 2013

Status
Not open for further replies.

karatekid552

What happens if I push it?....
    • 1,771
    Posts
    12
    Years
    Hack of the Year 2013 Results​

    Introduction

    So, I guess this is one those better late than never stories, haha. Over the past few months, there was a lot changes and some struggles going on behind the scenes in Emulation that made it tough to get everything organized. So, I am glad (and very thankful) that no one was beating down our pm boxes wondering what was taking so long.:P After playing through each hack, here we are with the final decisions of the year.

    -Please note that this thread is for posting congratulations only. Do not complain that your favourite hack didn't win, or be rude towards others in your posts.


    Drum roll please.....

    Results:

    The judges for 2013's Hack of the Year were Spherical Ice, doesntknowhowtoplay, DrFuji, and myself. It was quite obvious we all have different opinions on hacks, which provided for a pretty good variety in the judging. Here is a breakdown of how it all panned out along with each judge's score for the hacks:


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    "image removed"

    We also have a first, may I present: Slideshow Showcase's Hack of the Year!

    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    ​




    Now, we have a breakdown for each category that was voted for:


    Most Votes


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Most Engaging


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Best Scripting


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Best Storyline


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Best Mapping


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Best Graphics


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Best Gameplay


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013
    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013


    Fan Favourite


    [PokeCommunity.com] Results - 2013





    And a big thanks goes to.....
    Spherical Ice and DrFuji really kept this year's HotY together, even through some tough times, so please give them both a warm thank you. Spherical Ice also drew up all of the awards and was very helpful throughout!​




    Final Thoughts:


    Thank you to everyone here who made this competition possible. Remember that we can't have a hack of the year without any new hacks, so keep on mapping, scripting, coding, and most importantly, having fun! As we go throughout this new year, don't be afraid to try something new and... boldly go where no man has gone before? Yeah, that sounds about right.:) Remember to congratulate the winners and keep on delving deeper into the art of rom hacking. We hope to see you all back here next time! Good luck everyone.

    ~karatekid552







    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~​
     
    I Badly Wanted Glazed or Adventures to win! :/
    Anyways Congratulations To Linkandzelda For LC!
    Well done,Redriders and Rockman :D!Best Of the luck Next Time!
     
    I did play Liquid Crystal before, but never got the chance to try Glazed or Adventure Red. I will, though, at some point in future. :] Congrats to those who've won; you have all deserved it!
     
    Red Adventures was worked on very hard the whole year and became 1 of the top current ACTIVE hacks

    Glazed gets near 80 views in its thread every time i visit there, most people voted for it or Red Adventures to win and Glazed had updates too

    Liquid Crystal barely had any updates in 2013 most where small bug fixes and the hack should get a HOTY like years ago this time a new hack should get the spotlight if you know what i mean :D

    Like a guy said in the nominations thread the HOTY is a joke

    Just my opinion no offence to LaZ or his hack
     
    Well, at Least Two of My Favorite hacks Made it
    Glazed & Adventure Red These two well Deserved Hack of the Year 2013
    Both are The Best Played Last 2013 so That Cool :)
     
    Yes! Glazed deserved all the awards it received. Kudos to Lucbui for such an amazing hack. ^^
     
    glazed and adventure red r the most active hacks of year 2013.anyway congrats to creator of liquid crystal but still.
     
    destinedjagold said:
    I hope Doesn't will judge the next HotY.
    He's a good [Simon] judge. ;)
    Click to expand...
    Well... he doesn't know how to play, so it's plainly obvious he would be rating like that =D
    (I'm surprised he actually gave something more than 5, though =D)
     
    All three hacks are pretty impressive, and are enjoyable to play.
    My favorite was glazed, because of it's engaging story etc.
    But that the Second generation of all Pokemon, get this year the award is... I like that really much =)
    Satoshi Ookami said:
    Funny how Glazed took almost every possible award and still ended up second =D

    Congrats to LaZ and LC!
    Click to expand...

    Like you said 😂 and I you take it the other way around, LC doesn't get any awards or second places, and won this year. :)

    Congrats to all the three "winners"
     
    Well, congratulations to all, even though i hoped Glazed. I'm gonna play all 3 of them now and see the awesomness of Liquid Crystal myself.
     
    Congrats! I really actually wanted to vote for Glazed but I didn't vote for any of 'em. But I can't believe Glazed still came out as second ^^
     
    Hiroshi Kaede said:
    there should be Tool of the year next time
    Click to expand...
    This actually raises an interesting point. We shouldn't just be focusing on the hackers, particularly as most tend to use others' work (not that there's anything wrong with that). I think next year we should give recognition to the "behind the scenes" guys for want of a better word. Maybe something like "Best Tool", "Best Researcher" or something?

    I mean there's always the possibility of that devolving into a popularity contest and I don't know how measurable that would be, but it's an interesting idea at the very least.

    In any case, congrats to the winners! That judging looks really good I want to meet the judges and also the award creator and maybe sleep with them lmoa
     
    I actually didnt pay attention to the votes yesterday i just saw all the votes i think only karatekid had a clue on what his doing doesntknowhowtoplay gave a 1 on Glazes gameplay and 2 to reds story (a hack which story's is based on the manga) xD

    Well looking by the awards glazed and red won the most and fans voted them the most xD

    Id suggest keep karatekid and replace the 3 other judges for the 2014 hoty like add 3 judges who actually know something about Hacks

    Thank You
     
    ElitePokes said:
    Id suggest keep karatekid and replace the 3 other judges for the 2014 hoty like add 3 judges who actually know something about Hacks

    Thank You
    Click to expand...
    They do.

    I see nothing wrong with the "judgements" myself. doesnt is nothing but honest there. really.
    Giving that low ratings is kinda harsh, that is true. However, there are LOTS of things that can be improved with these projects; all of them. And I agree with the fact that none of them are close to being "perfect" and getting the rating of 40/40. No hack is.

    If you think about it, the scale between rating something is from 1 to 10. That means that getting 5 means that there already has to be some eye-catching content there and getting high ratings (like 8 or 9) means that you must have done outstanding job. And no pokemon hack out there is that outstanding. Writing a few neat scripts from scratch and possibly knowing how to make them run when a map is entered or something won't make your hack anything insane (that would be required to get high ratings). That doesn't mean that it couldn't be fun to play though.

    I do agree with all the other judges as well since giving low ratings makes others think, "Who are you to judge?" and things like that. If I was a judge, I wouldn't have been as negative as doesnt either, but I do think that I wouldn't have given any of them ratings higher than 25/40. Well maybe LC but I don't know about that either.
     
    You should play all 3 hacks at their latest versions... they are not perfect but they are good even better than the official gen 1-3 games xD

    A 5 out of 10 aint harsh but when you give 1-2 out of 10 then you are only asking for negative reactions
    I mean look at his name he doesntknowhowtoplay and in his details he put "some loser"
    How should i take that person seriously xD
     
    miksy91 said:
    They do.

    I see nothing wrong with the "judgements" myself. doesnt is nothing but honest there. really.
    Giving that low ratings is kinda harsh, that is true. However, there are LOTS of things that can be improved with these projects; all of them. And I agree with the fact that none of them are close to being "perfect" and getting the rating of 40/40. No hack is.

    If you think about it, the scale between rating something is from 1 to 10. That means that getting 5 means that there already has to be some eye-catching content there and getting high ratings (like 8 or 9) means that you must have done outstanding job. And no pokemon hack out there is that outstanding. Writing a few neat scripts from scratch and possibly knowing how to make them run when a map is entered or something won't make your hack anything insane (that would be required to get high ratings). That doesn't mean that it couldn't be fun to play though.

    I do agree with all the other judges as well since giving low ratings makes others think, "Who are you to judge?" and things like that. If I was a judge, I wouldn't have been as negative as doesnt either, but I do think that I wouldn't have given any of them ratings higher than 25/40. Well maybe LC but I don't know about that either.
    Click to expand...

    Before this breaks out into an argument, I did notice that my scores are very different. That is because I rated the hacks by taking away points, not giving them. When I saw a lacking of something or I was unsatisfied, I would decrease my score. I am very sure that everyone has a different method. As long as the method is consistent, that is all that matters.

    Code: 
    Let's break down these scores based upon score/40:

Sperical Ice
0.725 - G
0.7 - LC
0.5 - AR

Me
0.825 - G
0.8 - LC
0.725 - AR

doesntknowhowtoplay
0.375 - G
0.475 - LC
0.3 - AR

DrFuji
0.65 - G
0.7 - LC
0.525 - AR

By looking at these numbers, we also see that everyone has a threshold 
they won't leave. The largest gap is only .225 with most gaps being less 
than .2. This means that everyone's method was consistent.

Just looking at this % wise, here are the winners for each person:

Sperical Ice
G
LC
AR

Me
G
LC
AR

doesntknowhowtoplay
LC
G
AR

DrFuji
LC
G
AR

As you can see, 2 of use rated Glazed to be 1st and 2 rated LC to be 
first. When factored in with the overall decision that the community 
gave us:

LC
AR
G

We can see that LC is on top. Now, if we did deeper into the math and 
average the %s, we get:

G: (0.725+0.825+0.375+0.65)/4 = 0.644
LC: (0.7+0.8+0.475+0.7)/4 = 0.669
AR: (0.5+0.725+0.3+0.525)/4 = 0.513
    As you can see from the average of the percents, it still works out the same as when we simply counted up the scores. I know this last math doesn't include the fan favourite, but that still doesn't have enough leverage to change decision even if it was factored in. If the fans had rated Glazed #1, then yes, it could have changed it, but that didn't happen.

    The lesson here is that the size of the score doesn't matter, it is what the score is in relation to the other scores that that judge gave that does matter. Every single person did not deviate by more than 25% between their highest and lowest scored hacks. This shows a very balanced opinion.

    Also, by giving a low score, you get a little mad, right? Well, being mad is the first step to getting things done. People have made me angry beyond belief before and all it does is drive me to become better. G3HS is a great example of a project I started because I was mad at several different things. If we all gave perfect scores, people would feel that there is no room for improvement.


    The point of this was to settle any and all arguments over the judge's method of scoring. If you want to discuss my views on this, pm me. I will not respond to this conversation on here and I will delete any responses personally. This is a warning since this thread is about congratulating the hackers, NOT complaining.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top