[ABP #12] The Pile of Sludge and the Landshark!

[Kirbychu]

Poor Staraptor got smashed. ;(

VS

These Pokemon scare me.​

 

[Kenshin5]

I am only going with Muk cause I have yet too watch most of DP, so I really can't say that I like his character. But the little guy did hold his own for a bit against Darkrai (or at least longer then Torkoal). I think Gible has a chance of being a powerhouse if it evolves in a filler saga (post main Saga). I like Muk even though we barely got too see much of him outside of his loving reactions towards say Oak and anyone else. It did get some battles in at Indigo and Silver Conference and at Oaks Lab otherwise not much is seen out of him. I personally would like too see him in a battle or too either in a league or post saga. And it was kind of a same he wasn't apart of Battle Frontier either.

 

[Mew~]

It's going to be Muk for me.

I've always thought it was really funny. The first time it really ever shined to me was when it was in that battle with Jeanette's Bellsprout. It's always funny seeing it smothering Oak or Ash.

As for Gible, well - I found it pretty boring, it hardly had any personality. Most of the time that I remember of it was trying to master Draco Meteor, and it hiting Piplup, which was funny but only on Piplup's side if you ask me. :3

So yeah, "MMUUUUKKKKK!"

 

[psyanic]

Oh they both deserve more screen time. Muk was hardly used after it got caught, but I loved its fun personality and such. It's a good battler too, where it was seen in parts of the Indigo and Silver Conference, tanking its way through.

Gible was interesting, it met Ash attempting to master Draco Meteor and other stuff. It was fun to watch how it would use Bite in odd ways, such as biting Conway's Dusknoir in the Lily of the Valley Conference.

When it comes down to it, I prefer Muk. It just kind of wins with personality and battling, IMO.

 

[Charicific]

Haha! at last. An easy one for me! I will most definitely choose gible! That thing is funny, strong, and it evolves into one of the most impressive ubers there is. It's design is also distinguishable.

I don't hate muk though, but he was useless most of the time. Eventhough I laugh whenever he covers oak, i still see he isnt much of a use. He is a.........sludge? I don't feel comfortable with that.

 

[Perriechu]

My vote goes to Gible. It was quite strong once it mastered Draco Meteor. It was humorous to watch it try and learn the move. Muk didn't really seem all that interesting to me since it never got any character development. It was affectionate towards Oak and Tracey and that's it. It had some slight battle experience. I wish Ash had taken it along with him during the Battle Frontier saga. \;

 

[marcc5m]

Voting for Muk. Gible was completely pointless and was only there so Ash could have a dragon type. I mean Gliscor could've been replaced with something cool like Abomasnow, but nooooo, it had to be Gible.

Hear that? That's the sound of tough not being here.

 

[Wings Don't Cry]

You know that moment when Ash and Gible give each other that intense stare and then Gible jumps up and starts biting his head, that itself just gives him my vote and the fact that he finally gave what Piplup deserved.

 

[Squirrel]

Gotta be gible, that little cutie is so full of personality and when it finally masters draco meteor it really is a site to behold. Has so much potential!

 

[Polizard]

In this round i don't care either way but Muk slightly edges out Gible for me on this one.

 

[PlatinumDude]

It was hard for me to decide, but in the end, I went with Gible because of how it perfected Draco Meteor in the Pokemon League. I also like how it was able to eat almost anything, like Barry's bike.