American Idol!

So far,Who's you'r favorite American Idol?

  • Total voters
    7
Well, it looks like Carrie won. Congrats to her.
 
yeah!yay!im soo happy i was cring that night!im gonna be 1st to buy her cd!;)
 
*sigh* I'm still pissed that Bo didn't win...I've been ranting for days. o_o;
 
its okay he'll still put out a cd.just not as soon as carrie that's all.
 
im like in love with that song carrie sang when she won,um her 1st single...
 
I watched all of Idol 4 (mainly because my sisters were in it) and I was very dissapointed to see Carrie win. She really wasn't that good, because every country song she sang was off key, but to the audience who never listens to country, it was really good! And the whole season was based off of popularity. I personally wanted Vonzelle (sp) to win because she had a really powerful voice and was idol material. Or Constantine and Bo. Did you see the look on the Idol's faces when Constantine left??!! They were SO shocked!! Anywho... I think the ONLY idol who deserved to win throughout all of the season is Kelly. No one could ever replace her. She deserves to be the ONLY idol....but I know I'm going to watch season 5, just because I <3 american idol!!
 
i know kelly is the 1st and best idol so far!she's the only one who stood out to me so far.but carrie's next!
 
ash_misty4ever said:
I was very dissapointed to see Carrie win. She really wasn't that good, because every country song she sang was off key, but to the audience who never listens to country, it was really good!
Click to expand...

You're right, she was off key in all the songs that the judges claimed she was in her element while singing. They tend to pack the audience intentionally with unthinking ditzes who cheer at anything positive, boo at anything negative, and have no care for the actual quality of the singers, thus giving the illusion that Carrie pulled everything off perfectly. The show is always a bit rigged--notice that the people they profile the most from the beginning of the show usually end up making it to the top twelve. I've also noticed the judges use reverse psychology on the viewer; they will insult some people so unfairly that the viewer will vote for that person in defiance.

Technically, as far as people who have won the competition go, Kelly is still the most deserving, but as far as anyone who has ever participated in the show, I believe that it is a tie between Clay Aiken and Bo Bice.

I did love Scooter Girl from season three more than anyone, but she didn't advance past the round of 64 ;_________;
 
oh okay,if you think that.oh did y'all hear about kelly,how she doesnt want to do anything with american idol anymore.she doesnt want to go to the shows or anything.she just wants to get a way from it.
 
i dont know but thats what she said.
 
T_T I still feel so bad that Bo didnt win.. He really, really deserved it..
 
X3; Chairman Kaga - That makes me feel better X3; If Bo won, who knows what producers might have made of him XD
 
no so not farther,but idont know???i just know carries going to make an impacted on music.
 
Thanks to PokemonMstrSpiro in the other thread for posting the winner's name in the thread title and spoiling it for those of us who haven't got around to watching the taped final episode yet. >_>
 
Dignity said:
X3; Chairman Kaga - That makes me feel better X3; If Bo won, who knows what producers might have made of him XD
Click to expand...

I think I said in one of these American Idol topics that he would have become an old, hairy Hilary Duff...thank goodness he was spared that fate XD

I actually saw him perform on Regis & Kelly yesterday morning. He rocked my socks bigtime. And did you know his name is acutally Harold Bice? Bo comes from his childhood nickname of Bogart XD
 
hey everyone!yeah!carrie's cd comes out in like 12 days!im gonna get it!
 
I flat out refuse to buy Carrie's CD. The artist has to spend at least a year on the album...or I won't buy it. It'll probably be crap, no matter how good of a singer she is.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top