Arcanine or Ninetales?

[Citrinin]

The mysteriousness of Ninetales has always appealed to me. XD; So, Ninetales. ^^

 

[XxDawnfanxX]

I love Ninetales design, it is a very strong evolution pokemon and its tales make it look awesome. I would also love having an Arcanine as well because it is a strong fire pokemon that I could ride on its back.

 

[Oh The Places You'll Go.]

Yeah,
Well, >.>
Nintales.
The reason, it's prettier.

 

[RainDogg54]

Ninetales. It has 9x as many tails as Arcanine. So therefore Ninetales>Arcanine

 

[poopnoodle]

Ninetales. It has 9x as many tails as Arcanine. So therefore Ninetales>Arcanine

I think Arcanine's massive tail makes up for its lack of eight more.

 

[Scarlet the plusle]

I think Arcanine's massive tail makes up for its lack of eight more.

arcanine's tail is 9x less fluffy! and he needs to be brushed!

 

[Timbjerr]

Let's see...Arcanine has a higher BST, but lacks variety in movepool...while Ninetales is the inverse... As far as appearances go, I prefer Arcanine actually (has always preferred an intimidating-looking pokemon over an elegant-looking pokemon), but kitsune are cooler than ryukyuan...bah!!

I'll have to go with Arcanine on this one or else Andy will kill me. >_<

 

[Åzurε]

Aw, tough decision. They kinda compliment each other, don't they? If I added up points, I'd say Ninetales wins, but only for having a major role in a spin-off game. Mystery Dungeon Red/Blue for those with questions.

 

[mikey]

Arcanine has my vote, I never liked Ninetales much. Arcanine is awesome.

 

[Lockerz]

I like both so it's hard to choose. Ummm...could I just say that Houndoom pwns both of them and run off? Nah, I can't. This is difficult!!

Spoiler:

Ninetales

Yup Houndoom is my favorite but out of Ninetails and Arcanine I would pick Arcanine. I think Arcanine has a better move set and is better to have in a party. Just my opinion.

 

[Kitty!]

Aw, I've always really wanted an Arcanine. They're so big, fast and ..well, I find them totally cute. ;D

Ninetails is beautiful, and I do like it as well. But Arcanine is one of my all time favorites.

 

[Dr Gregory House]

WhaaaAAAAaaaat????
How is Ninetales winning? :|
Arcanine is obviously cooler.
:3

 

[Fate Falls]

Like a lot of other people, it seems, my choice is really, really close too, but I think I'd go with Arcanine. I'm a dog lover, and I think it's great that Growlithe and Arcanine can follow orders and be used as police dogs and are really loyal and wise.

 

[Sonikku]

Nietails is elegant, strong and has way better moves onece you get down to it

 

[derozio]

Arcanine > Ninetales coz:
He has much better stats and he looks more elegant and royal to me! XD

 

[Lycaeus]

Awesome to see everyone's opinion (:
Looks like it's a 20/18 lead for Arcanine.

 

[XtinaIsMeLuvinWWE]

I honestly do like Arcanine and everything... but...

NINETALES FTW!!!!!!!!! :D

 

[Lycaeus]

21/19 lead for Arcanine :D
Anyone else have an opinion?