• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Do think Brock will leave Generation 5?

Opinions

  • Brock

    Votes: 12 23.1%

  • Dawn

    Votes: 40 76.9%
  • Total voters
    52
Status
Not open for further replies.
Alpha_Spike said:
I have a theory based on this. If you notice they have a set trend. Brock and Misty journeyed with Ash in Kanto and Johto, Misty also journeyed in Orange Islands. Brock got gen 3 and 4 with small appearances from Misty. Now my theory is that they could possibly have Misty return for the next two gens(if a gen 6 ever comes out) and have a new male with small appearances from Brock. It would be better plus there is the chemistry between Misty and Ash....Pokeshipping XD
Click to expand...

Sorry, in an interview with a person who works on the show said they'll never have Misty back in the main cast again.
They keep switching girls to draw in male fans.
Dispite how much I want Dawn to stay.
I like the chemistry between DawnxAsh, just me though.
 
PearlShipper4Life said:
Sorry, in an interview with a person who works on the show said they'll never have Misty back in the main cast again.
They keep switching girls to draw in male fans.
Dispite how much I want Dawn to stay.
I like the chemistry between DawnxAsh, just me though.
Click to expand...
That interview was 3 or 4 years ago. They might change their minds.
 
As the person above me said they may have changed their minds. Its possible that they will follow the theme they seem to have going or they could change the whole main crew and have 3 entirely new people with cameo's from Ash and the gang but who knows.
 
Seriously?
It was during the time they were working on Dimond and Pearl.
I dought things will change.
But hey, if they change the whole changing girls every Generation thing and let Dawn stay and throw away Brock than I'm all for it.
Guess will wait and see.
 
Personally, I'm rooting for both of them to leave.

Although, I know it won't happen.. only Dawn. xD;
 
I think it'll be Dawn.. Brock's like a permanent cast already.

TBH I like Brock, without him, Pokemon series wouldn't be wacky. XD
 
Darthbane2007 said:
As Orange Islands showed us, Ash is capable of fending for himself without brock.
Click to expand...

Its true.
Course Tracey was in place of Brock and fans whined about it back than.
Which is why I think the producers/writers are afraid to replace him again.
 
I dont really know what to believe anymore, I mean Brock as been neglected in the Sinnoh region having only 3 crappy pokemon and nothing else, hardly ever battles, and hardly even has protagonism.
 
Most likely Brock will stay on. They did get rid of him for awhile, but he came back. I do wish he had a better character this season :/
 
PearlShipper4Life said:
Its true.
Course Tracey was in place of Brock and fans whined about it back than.
Which is why I think the producers/writers are afraid to replace him again.
Click to expand...

I honestly doubt that was the reason. If it was, they would have been fearful of replacing ANY of the characters without receiving backlash, never mind Brock. In other words, they would not have even dared to replace Misty if that was truly the reason.

Honestly, why isn't there a poll option for "both?" I know I want both to be removed.
 
Unfortunately, like every region, Ash will dump Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* and go with Brock (usually) to a new region called Johto/Hoenn/Sinnoh/*insert region's name*. On occasion, Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* will appear in a short arc but to displease Poke/Advance/Pearl/*whatever* shippers, they leave quickly as they came. Ash, being the pimp he is, will probably forget about Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* and meet some new chick he randomly met that he decided to follow a total stranger. On the other hand, Ash always keeps Brock because they have FUn time he's a slave to Ash, cooking his food , giving pointless advice, etc. During the trio trip in Johto/Hoenn/Sinnoh/*insert region's name*, viewers see Ash's crappy attempt at training Pokemon, Brock getting PWNED for hitting on women and an actual attempt for Ash actually get to know Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* bonding and perhaps making Poke/Advance/Pearl/*whatever* shipping to seem almost canon but after Ash get all 8 badges and competes in the Johto/Hoenn/Sinnoh/*insert region's name*'s Conference, he will decided to get rid of Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* like the big pimp he is and continue a long, long cycle.

tl;dr Dawn will leave and Ash is a pimp.


Content from Sudeki included.
 
Last edited:
missingnoresearcher said:
Unfortunately, like every region, Ash will dump Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* and go with Brock (usually) to a new region called Johto/Hoenn/Sinnoh/*insert region's name*. On occasion, Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* will appear in a short arc but to displease Poke/Advance/Pearl/*whatever* shippers, they leave quickly as they came. Ash, being the pimp he is, will probably forget about Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* and meet some new chick he randomly met that he decided to follow a total stranger. After Ash get all 8 badges and competes in the Johto/Hoenn/Sinnoh/*insert region's name*'s Conference, he will decided to get rid of Misty/May/Dawn/*insert name* and continue a long, long cycle.

tl;dr Dawn will leave and Ash is a pimp.
Click to expand...
I so agree xD, I bet he only keeps brock for the free food.
 
As long as Ash is the series' protagonist, Brock will stay in his group.

Dawn will leave Ash's group by the end of DP. I can see her coming back for a few episodes in Generation V like Misty did in AG and May did in DP if Generation V's female character is yet another coordinator. Having Dawn appear in Generation V would otherwise be pointless, since the series would no longer be covering contests.
 
Jado said:
As long as Ash is the series' protagonist, Brock will stay in his group.

Dawn will leave Ash's group by the end of DP. I can see her coming back for a few episodes in Generation V like Misty did in AG and May did in DP if Generation V's female character is yet another coordinator. Having Dawn appear in Generation V would otherwise be pointless, since the series would no longer be covering contests.
Click to expand...
how do you know dawn will stay? nothing has been offically stated.
 
MastaMind said:
how do you know dawn will stay? nothing has been offically stated.
Click to expand...
I said she would leave, not that she would stay.

In one interview, it was stated that the writers replace the main girl with a new one after each saga for the sake of providing young male viewers of the show with fresh fanservice (sexist, huh?). Like Misty and May before her, Dawn will leave at the end of DP and be replaced with another female character.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top