G/S Remake for Special? Should it happen?

[Taichi]

Since the 2nd Gen remakes are confirmed, you think Pokemon Special should have a HG/SS arc with Gold, Silver, and Kris back?

Discuss.

 

[Thundєr]

I hope so, Crys is one of my fav characters, and her arc was brilliant. I think yes.

 

[Fixen]

They better. I'm slightly annoyed at the DPP arc so far...mostly because I haven't played the game and really don't feel like it, and I also don't think it's got a good storyline coming.

 

[Mika555]

I think there will be a HGSS arc in Pokemon Special, but it probably will not begin until next year when the Platinum arc reaches its climax.

 

[ZestyCactus]

I don't see why not. They had a FRLG arc, so why not HGSS?

 

[Wyyrlokk]

I hope so. The arc was the best I´ve read so far. And Johto is my favourite of the Pokemon countries, too.

(Quite funny... Nintendo confirms that remake... today, I guess, and immediately such a discussion starts. xD)

 

[RubyJB88]

If games are confirmed, then surely a new arc will be too.

 

[RedJ]

Funny, I was just speculating about this :P
But yeah, I too smell a HG/SS arc.

 

[auragirl]

I prey that they do, Gold, silver a crys are awesome! They need another arc!

 

[pong08]

I really hope that there's more character development in that arc.... and I just want it to become a more of a adventure/romance as the arcs continue.

 

[Idiot!]

They will have an arc, as long as the HGSS has a sidequest that GSC doesn't.

 

[the reborn sky]

i hope it does, i want to see the other 9 pokedex holders with some sinnoh pokemon. but there's got to be some radically new feature, not just another battle frontier, or its just a repaet of emerald arc.

 

[nssfleahedgehog]

Well, how else will we know Giovanni's fate?

 

[Aine]

Yes! That was one of my favorite arcs! Squee! Does that mean the original 10 will be showing up again? :D

 

[Wallace Berlitz]

Hmm... I don't really think the 10 will be back again in HeartGold and SoulSilver. I believe only half of them, not all 13. At least Kanto + Johto Pokedex Owners. Like FireRed and LeafGreen. They only have Kanto + Johto since they are not third installment of the games. A high chance that all the 13 Pokedex Owners will reunion in Platinum.

 

[invisible-chan]

I'm pretty sure it'll merge into the DPPt arc as FR/LG did with RSE.

 

[Clover Cat]

Well, out of all the Dex Holders, the Johto members have probably had the least amount of screen time (I mean, we never did find out what Gold has been doing these past several arcs), and then there's the deal with Giovanni. And I'm not sure that the Dex Holder's reunion will be in Platinum, since I suspect Miss Berlitz is trying to free the Sinnoh pokedex holders at this point. Oh, and I was rereading Emerald and found something interesting-there's a panel where Guile Hideout talks about how he's going to try to find the 'Sea Mirage Pokemon' after he takes over the battle frontier. Behind him, Manaphy appears as a sillouhete. That could be a possible plot. Then there's Pryce. I do so hope he'll be back :).

 

[Mika555]

Well, out of all the Dex Holders, the Johto members have probably had the least amount of screen time (I mean, we never did find out what Gold has been doing these past several arcs), and then there's the deal with Giovanni.

Yes the Pokemon Special writers do leave a lot of plotholes.

I think that the Pichu-Colored Pichu and the Notched-Ear Pichu will be featured in the HGSS arc of Pokemon Special since they were shown in the HGSS game screenshots, but this is all just speculations at this point.

And I'm not sure that the Dex Holder's reunion will be in Platinum, since I suspect Miss Berlitz is trying to free the Sinnoh pokedex holders at this point.

Spoiler:

I do not think it was reveal what happened to Dia and Pearl at this point?

 

[Taemin]

I hope it does, but at the same time, the HG/SS storyline will stay the same, so there'd be no point in re-telling the same storyline over again in the manga, obviously. >_> Although it would be cool if some of the characters at least made re-appearances, even for a short time.

 

[Clover Cat]

@ Mika555: Considering how much attention those two Pichus are getting, that's a good chance. I'm still going with Manaphy, though.

Hmmm...I wonder which Dex Holders would appear? Gold, Crys, Silver, obviously...Maybe Ruby, although I hope the arc wouldn't follow the exact same lines as FR/LG did.