Gen 5? *scoffs* enough allready (also the old female protagonist appreciation thread)

[Matt.K]

Honestly, the Pokemon franchise is going TOO FAR with this

(Damn it! if only I could post links, but I'm telling you, anime director Masamitsu Hidaka confirmed Gen 5 himself, so don't flame me for pointless ranting!)

Generation 4 was my favourite, and the last that I would tolerate. What the hell are they going to make out of the new legendaries? (If it's something that is yet again more powerful than the last generation I'm going to shoot myself. For pete's sake, Arceus is the god of all Pokemon, Dialga controls time and Palkia controls space. That's been settled).
And with each generation the Pokemon get more cartoony, I mean Gen 4 Pokemon were quite cartoonish but still loveable. As for Gen 5... I can't imagine it. As I said in another post, Dialga and Palkia are as unrealisticaly Play-doh looking as Pokemon can get. What's it going to be in Gen 5? SOMETHING THAT RESEMBLES MICKEY MOUSE??? I can't take any more! Then they'll just get to the point where they resemble neither animals OR monsters!
Oh yes, and also the fact of the main female protagonist being replaced YET AGAIN. Honestly, after they replace Dawn, I'm going to say "you know what, forget this" and I won't watch or play any of the Pokemon anime or games after Gen 4. It's just going to be me, my DVDs of the good old Diamond and Pearl series and my beautiful AU fanfic, IN WHICH GEN 5, OR ANY FUTURE GENERATION FOR THAT MATTER DOESN'T HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT!
Come on, many of us have felt the pain of our fave female protagonist being replaced and never seen again besides a few episodes during the next Gen. Especialy all you Misty fans out there who stopped watching Pokemon after Misty left; you may not be big Dawn fans like I am, but at least you have a similar story.
And this ain't just about female protagonists, this is about all Gen exclusive characters (eg. Drew, Harley, Nando, Zoey).
When Dawn leaves and the new Pokemon come reeling in, I'm saying goodbye to the Pokemon canon; though I will always love the concept of Pokemon.

P.S. Satoshi Tajiri has already served a great purpose, now he's just going for nothing but the money with whatever crummy future designs Ken Sugimori can think of. Such a shame...

 

[MastaMind]

https://www.pokecommunity.com/threads/204706

you just proved my point

 

[A Pixy]

Right off the bat, let me say this:

Now that I've said that, let's move on, shall we?

Honestly, the Pokemon franchise is going TOO FAR with this

It hasn't come yet, how do you know it's going to suck? And this isn't like the Sonic franchise where a game is more likely to suck then not suck. This is friggin' Pokemon. Something we know is going to deliver. GEN5 isn't going to suck if logic dictates.

(Damn it! if only I could post links, but I'm telling you, anime director Masamitsu Hidaka confirmed Gen 5 himself, so don't flame me for pointless ranting!)

THEY'RE MAKING A GEN5? OMFG, I TTLY DIDN'T SEE THAT ONE COMING! 8O

Generation 4 was my favourite, and the last that I would tolerate.

1. GEN2 is the best, hands down. IMO
2. If we tolerated 10 years of these games, I think we can take another fourth of a decade with them.

What the hell are they going to make out of the new legendaries? (If it's something that is yet again more powerful than the last generation I'm going to shoot myself. For pete's sake, Arceus is the god of all Pokemon, Dialga controls time and Palkia controls space. That's been settled).

Those legendaries attached to the stories of the anime and the games, it was necessary to make them as powerful as they were.

And with each generation the Pokemon get more cartoony,

I think that the Pokemon have been perpetually being cartoony and all serious looking. Each one has it's handful of cartoony Pokemon (Lickitung, Dunsparce, Chimeco and Bidoof) and each have their own handful of serious looking ones (Charizard, Tyranitar, Salemence and Luxray).

I mean Gen 4 Pokemon were quite cartoonish but still loveable. As for Gen 5... I can't imagine it.

I can't imagine it either. So when they DO come around, I know how awesome/freaky they're going to look.

As I said in another post, Dialga and Palkia are as unrealisticaly Play-doh looking as Pokemon can get. What's it going to be in Gen 5? SOMETHING THAT RESEMBLES MICKEY MOUSE???

If you're being satirical, AHAHAHAHAHA- not funny.
If you're not, please hang up and try again.

I can't take any more! Then they'll just get to the point where they resemble neither animals OR monsters!

I don't even want to think about what that could possibly look like. -_-

Oh yes, and also the fact of the main female protagonist being replaced YET AGAIN.

So what? I don't see what could separate Leaf, Kris, Kotone, May or Dawn. Sure, some will be remembered, but they must change to suit the mood of the series. And because if we had the same one over and over again I would get bored.

Honestly, after they replace Dawn, I'm going to say "you know what, forget this" and I won't watch or play any of the Pokemon anime or games after Gen 4.

That my friend, is something YOU must sort out. If you have a special place in your heart for Dawn, SUPAH.

It's just going to be me, my DVDs of the good old Diamond and Pearl series and my beautiful AU fanfic,

1. Yeah, sure, female protaganists have come and gone, does this mean the new one is going to suck?
2. DON'T FRIGGIN' PLUG YOURSELF LIKE THAT! D8<

IN WHICH GEN 5, OR ANY FUTURE GENERATION FOR THAT MATTER DOESN'T HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT!

Then you're missing out.

Come on, many of us have felt the pain of our fave female protagonist being replaced and never seen again besides a few episodes during the next Gen.

They need to move on because of a new generation. This is a show trying to market video games. They need to market the games so they get rid of the old female so they can bring in the new one. You are watching a 30 minute toy ad. DON'T THINK SO DEEPLY ABOUT IT!

Especialy all you Misty fans out there who stopped watching Pokemon after Misty left;

THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO STOPPED WATCHING POKEMON BECAUSE OF MISTY LEFT?

WTF?

Even my older brother who never watched Pokemon thinks that's stupid!

you may not be big Dawn fans like I am, but at least you have a similar story.

Look, there is nothing wrong with missing a character or two. I miss Drew, I miss May, I miss Harley, I miss Misty. But that doesn't mean the show sucks without them! The show's been doing the same thing perpetually for 10 straight years! IT HASN'T CHANGED!

And this ain't just about female protagonists, this is about all Gen exclusive characters (eg. Drew, Harley, Nando, Zoey). When Dawn leaves and the new Pokemon come reeling in, I'm saying goodbye to the Pokemon canon; though I will always love the concept of Pokemon.

Then, once again, YOU ARE MISSING OUT!

P.S. Satoshi Tajiri has already served a great purpose, now he's just going for nothing but the money with whatever crummy future designs Ken Sugimori can think of. Such a shame...

Of course they want money. It's fans like us who keeps GIVING THESE GUYS THE MONEY!

So, in summation.

Thank you for reading this tl;dr and we hope you enjoyed reading this.

 

[joehat]

Eheh actually I hate to be the one to say it but..you just said yourself that generation IV was your favorite. You really don't think that you'll like generation V equally as much? You're different, as in most people that make rant threads like this are the ones who love the first or second generation and only them. I for one, am completely in favor of a generation V. Sure, Pokemon is one of the ultimate cash cow franchises but I'll continue buying the (main) games and watching the show haha.

 

[Vernikova]

You're an idiot and you should feel bad about yourself. If you don't care for another generation just stop associating yourself with the stupid franchise and leave it.

 

[Matt.K]

You're an idiot and you should feel bad about yourself. If you don't care for another generation just stop associating yourself with the stupid franchise and leave it.

You can't tell me what I can and can't do outside of this forum. I think I deserve freedom of speech, I'm making an arguement here, not starting a flaming war.

 

[Vernikova]

You can't tell me what I can and can't do outside of this forum. I think I deserve freedom of speech, I'm making an arguement here, not starting a flaming war.

If you're tired of these new Pokémon, why play the new games? Instead of complaining about it save yourself the pain and misery and cut it. Complaining doesn't do anything and won't resolve any problem that you have with the franchise.

Also, your argument sucks. You can save yourself the trouble of seeing weirder Pokémon by stop buying their products. It's obvious that they're going to create more Pokémon because the games are still popular so it's a "So . . .yeah." in this situation. The creators don't care what power some Pokémon had because they only want money and will continue to do so.

Thirdly, Freedom of Speech won't protect you from other people calling you an idiot or anything else.

 

[Spinor]

You can't tell me what I can and can't do outside of this forum. I think I deserve freedom of speech, I'm making an arguement here, not starting a flaming war.

Freedom of speech my foot. That's only for you to complain against the government. In fact, all the world governments would be better if people like you just shut your traps and left alone these freaking cartoons if you don't like them anymore.

 

[Matt.K]

If you're tired of these new Pokémon, why play the new games? Instead of complaining about it save yourself the pain and misery and cut it. Complaining doesn't do anything and won't resolve any problem that you have with the franchise.

Also, your argument sucks. You can save yourself the trouble of seeing weirder Pokémon by stop buying their products. It's obvious that they're going to create more Pokémon because the games are still popular so it's a "So . . .yeah." in this situation. The creators don't care what power some Pokémon had because they only want money and will continue to do so.

Thirdly, Freedom of Speech won't protect you from other people calling you an idiot or anything else.

I just said I'm not going to play the games! And as for you saying my arguement sucks, yeah well that's real nice ya know (being a bit more specific will help a lot too). I think you're now just having a personal bias against me, so unless you have a decent mannered response, why don't you just stop spamming this thread, eh? I think all you people are taking this too personally and going crazy just because I have a negative vision of Gen 5. And besides, this is thread my OPINION, so stop arguing like a baby.

 

[Spinor]

We don't want your opinion. We want discussions. That's what forums are for, silly.

 

[Matt.K]

We don't want your opinion. We want discussions. That's what forums are for, silly.

This thread has potential to open a legitimate discussion of whether people can look forward to Gen 5 or not, instead of hoarding in a pack of smart-alecs who simply disregard my discussion as a whole.

 

[randomspot555]

Honestly, the Pokemon franchise is going TOO FAR with this

Generation 4 was my favourite, and the last that I would tolerate. What the hell are they going to make out of the new legendaries? (If it's something that is yet again more powerful than the last generation I'm going to shoot myself. For pete's sake, Arceus is the god of all Pokemon, Dialga controls time and Palkia controls space. That's been settled).

Arceus is "the god of all Pokemon" according to what? And in what capacity? Even going with that Arceus is divine (which is certainly debatable at best), look at Japan's indigenous religion, Shinto. They have various gods of elements and stuff, and their big/head gods are distant creatures rarely referenced who delegate their power. So Arceus is the Creator god, but that's IT. He's nothing more, nothing less.

And so what? Back in Gen I (FIRST GENERATION), Mewtwo was the STRONGEST Pokemon there is, and it was cloned from a Pokemon that can supposedly LEARN EVERY MOVE and has the GENETIC MAKEUP OF ALL POKEMON in it.

Did Gamefreak, Nintendo, and the anime production staff throw their hands up in the air and say "Well, we can't top THE MOST POWERFUL, can we? I wonder if that new Barbie Princess game has a programer yet?"

And with each generation the Pokemon get more cartoony, I mean Gen 4 Pokemon were quite cartoonish but still loveable. As for Gen 5... I can't imagine it. As I said in another post, Dialga and Palkia are as unrealisticaly Play-doh looking as Pokemon can get. What's it going to be in Gen 5? SOMETHING THAT RESEMBLES MICKEY MOUSE??? I can't take any more! Then they'll just get to the point where they resemble neither animals OR monsters!

You're playing a game called Pocket Monsters that's been merchandised from almost every angle, and you're complaining about them looking TOO cartoony?

P.S. Satoshi Tajiri has already served a great purpose, now he's just going for nothing but the money with whatever crummy future designs Ken Sugimori can think of. Such a shame...

Satoshi Tajiri is, as far as I know, inactive from Gamefreak entirely. According to Nob Ogasawara, the former translator for the series, he found out this:

I ask around, but all anyone will say is, "He's still broken and getting treatments."

source

 

[Vernikova]

I just said I'm not going to play the games!

There was no reason for you to quote my first post then nor is there a reason for you to complain.

And as for you saying my arguement sucks, yeah well that's real nice ya know (being a bit more specific will help a lot too).

How can I be more specific about an event that has yet to occur and that no information has been released about? It's like complaining about something that you don't know anything about, which this is.

I think you're now just having a personal bias against me,

If you want to take it that way. I act like this every time I disagree with someone.

so unless you have a decent mannered response, why don't you just stop spamming this thread, eh?

Why don't you stop spamming this forum because this is in the wrong section, eh? Also, if you come up with a decent argument I'll have a semi-mannered response.

I think all you people are taking this too personally and going crazy just because I have a negative vision of Gen 5. And besides, this is thread my OPINION, so stop arguing like a baby.

Your complaining about something you don't even know about yet. Stop complaining like a baby if you can't accept other's opinions on your, very premature, opinion.

 

[Sweet Smoochum]

I actually don't mind a new generation of Pokemon. (I have 400 of the 493 pokemon already and have a bunch of level 100s and other high level pokemon, so showing us some new Pokemon helps.) Personally, I didn't find this current generation that interesting anime-wise because of certain pokemon trainers, but the new Japanese intro changed my mind and I'm interested again. (I saw Ash with BAYLEEF. <333) The Sinnoh pokemon were more appealing to me than the ones in third gen. Skuntank, Toxicroak, Drapion, Infernape, Torterra, Togekiss, Happiny, Luminion, and Bonsly are some of my fourth gen favorites.

I'm a Misty fan, but I haven't stopped watching the anime entirely just because she left. (I actually thought she would come back later in the series since Brock did, but then I read that interview on Pokebeach just last year. But since the old director is no longer in charge, I'll take what he said about her not coming back as a main character with a grain of salt. You never know what the future holds. Note: Pokethlon seems like something Misty could do.) Personally, I like Kotone more than Dawn. Chikorita was my first ever Pokemon, so I'm happy she has one, too. :D I hope Kotone appears in the intro when Ash goes to the battle frontier.

Tldr; version--I'm looking forward to gen 5. (You know they're going to have to top HeartGold and SoulSilver.)

 

[Matt.K]

I actually don't mind a new generation of Pokemon. (I have 400 of the 493 pokemon already and have a bunch of level 100s and other high level pokemon, so showing us some new Pokemon helps.) Personally, I didn't find this current generation that interesting anime-wise because of certain pokemon trainers, but the new Japanese intro changed my mind and I'm interested again. (I saw Ash with BAYLEEF. <333) The Sinnoh pokemon were more appealing to me than the ones in third gen. Skuntank, Toxicroak, Drapion, Infernape, Torterra, Togekiss, Happiny, Luminion, and Bonsly are some of my fourth gen favorites.

I'm a Misty fan, but I haven't stopped watching the anime entirely just because she left. (I actually thought she would come back later in the series since Brock did, but then I read that interview on Pokebeach just last year. But since the old director is no longer in charge, I'll take what he said about her not coming back as a main character with a grain of salt. You never know what the future holds. Note: Pokethlon seems like something Misty could do.) Personally, I like Kotone more than Dawn. Chikorita was my first ever Pokemon, so I'm happy she has one, too. :D I hope Kotone appears in the intro when Ash goes to the battle frontier.

Tldr; version--I'm looking forward to gen 5. (You know they're going to have to top HeartGold and SoulSilver.)

Finally! Someone with a decently sophisticated response. Thank you!

 

[Pokémon Ranger ✩ Moriarty]

This thread has potential to open a legitimate discussion of whether people can look forward to Gen 5 or not, instead of hoarding in a pack of smart-alecs who simply disregard my discussion as a whole.

This thread has no way of forming legitimate discussions when the original post basically boils down to "bawww I won't stand for generation 5 happening and therefore it shouldn't!!11 WHERE MY DAWN FANS AT".

Nintendo don't give a hoot as to whether or not you're going to carry on watching the Anime or playing the games; as long as a franchise makes money then it's going to continue. And you yourself admit that they didn't do a shabby job with Generation IV, so why on Earth are you so biased against a Generation V? We don't know anything about it other than it's going to happen and that, obviously, it's going to have to top HG/SS (which are getting rave reviews everywhere). It's like saying the next Star Trek movie is going to suck despite this one being awesome even though all we know about it is that it's in Pre-Production and involves the same basic idea of a starship called the Enterprise.

As for the concept of Dawn leaving and a new character replacing her, that's what has to happen. Change has to happen, or a medium will become stale and unimaginative. It's your right to stop watching the show, but coming here and complaining all over the place with arguments that quite frankly defy logic (if Dialga and Palkia look like Play-Doh then what on Titan does Ditto look like to you?!) and an unwillingness to listen to anybody but yourself is a bit thick. I agree with Jorah, try to form a coherent argument that isn't all personal opinion and more people might try to listen to you. :/

 

[randomspot555]

Finally! Someone with a decently sophisticated response. Thank you!

Which is impressive considering the first post is complete crap. The guy who started this thread is criticizing an unreleased product that nothing is known about. What is up with that?

 

[A Pixy]

Or, to put my post in shorter terms:

Misty/May/Dawn/Drew etc. is never coming back and there's nothing you can do about it.

 

[weedle_mchairybug]

Or, to put my post in shorter terms:

Misty/May/Dawn/Drew etc. is never coming back and there's nothing you can do about it.

Oh, really? Then explain Brock returning? The writers could have easily kept him off even WITH the realization that most of the fanbase in America doesn't even care about his facial features, saying we don't matter, but they brought him back anyways.

Heck, they could have easily said that to Carol B. Weatherford in regards to Jynx, and make the entire hearing null and void, and kept having Jynx being black even up to this generation, but they succumbed to her will, wussed out, if you will.

If they can do it in those two instances, chances are we can do something about it if we put our mind to it.

 

[Co500]

im actually looking forward to Gen5 I hated Gen4 they all looked horrible but one question, wat system will it come out on because will it be possible to trade with HG/SS D/P/pt?