2nd Gen Gold, Silver, or Crystal?

Gold, Silver, or Crystal: Which is best?

  • Gold

    Votes: 21 16.8%

  • Silver

    Votes: 26 20.8%

  • Crystal

    Votes: 78 62.4%
  • Total voters
    125
SILVER 4 LYF!!!
I can't believe I said 'lyf!'

I like Silver version just because it was my first Pokemon Game. I enjoy crystal, but they put in some unnecessary changes. For example, you can't catch Ho-oh until you catch the three legendary dogs. And I don't have three Master Balls on hand!
 
Definitely Crystal for me.
Most of the reasons are listed by others so C:~~
 
Crystal for me because I never played the other two.
 
Crystal for reasons I don't even need to bother stating, but of them, I liked the gender choice the most.
 
Crystal. I liked crystal better because I loved the graphics.
 
definetly crystal! In my opinion it has better and u can play as a girl.
 
I don't think there's any real contest here, it's definitely Crystal. I'd say the fact that all the Pokemon are animated is reason enough.
 
Doesn't suprise me that everyones saying Crystal XD
Anyway, like nearly everyone else, its Crystal.

I like Crystal the best because it added animated sprites to the mix, had a more in-depth story, the mascot is Suicune and I love Suicune, you dont have to hunt down Suicune, there is a reward for catching all of the beasts
Spoiler:
, there are more battles, there is a new character..Eusine!, the story is longer, both Ho-oh and Lugia are at lv 70, there is a battle tower, you can now get 2 shinies easily (the egg you get from the daycare has a 1/8 chance of being shiny), you can be a GIRL (which I am :P), the Unown have been expanded on (now there are not that unknown XD) and finally, the radio has new features.

Bad things about Crystal is you cant catch Mareep (a decent Electric), some pokemon you find early you find really late in the game (such as Magmar) and if I am correct, Lugia and Ho-oh dont have or learn their signature moves :\
 
Crystal is the remastred version of G/S, it's normal that it's better. But the Japanese version has lots of bonus, for example a kind of "Global Trade Station" and a GS ball quest to get Celebi ;_;
 
im going for Crystal because its basicly better
 
I like Crystal better than the others, but Silver is cool too.
 
Well, the best for me has got to be Crystal because of it's improved graphics and storyline.
 
My personal favorite is gold, but crystal is definitely the better game. It's all the same stuff, but with more! The only reason I favor gold is that I put the most time into it, and grew attached to it ^_^
 
I loved Crystal the most. I used to have Silver, and I lost it. I've never had gold though. lol
 
I had Gold first, but Crystal was just amazing. I remember being so awed by the fact that the pokemon would actually move.
 
Crystal's probably the best for me :) But, I'll always be a great fan of Silver too - that game was just so good!

None of the newer ones have been as good as these three, for me :(
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top