Graphic Rating Thread

[MegaMan666]

Please rate ^___^

 

[DarkPegasus]

They look nice, but I can't really read what's belove PETA in the first sig.

it's okay... you took two planets, put them on a starfield.. it would have been nicer if you had put a sort of haze over the planets to make them look like they were already on the starfield.

The star field and the planets were made by my. I have photoshop for two weeks now, so I am still in the proces of learning... And if you by the haze mean atmopshere, then it there to prove it here are the pics:

 

[Strawberry Delcatty]

Are you sure you did it? Looks like a professional made it. Oh, well...

Comments, please.

 

[DarkPegasus]

Yea, I am sure I made it, I can post the *.psd file if you want.

 

[Sawyer]

you didn't make that. it's impossible to make such a thing in PS from scratch. and frankly, i wouldn't have cared if you had said you used someone else's planets, but lying about it is bad, since i can tell when you are.

 

[DarkPegasus]

It isn't possible you say? Then I guess there are alot of artists that are thiefs around devianart... Just to prove I made those here is the zip with psd files of both planets(attached), and a link to the tutorial for planet making:

https://gallery.artofgregmartin.com/tuts_arts/making_a_planet.html

 

[Sylver]

Yeah, he made it, nice job, thanks for the tut btw, might be useful for the feature.

 

[DarkPegasus]

Thanks! Finally somebady who belives me...

 

[Strawberry Delcatty]

I believe you too, DP. Just so you know.

Comments, please.

 

[MystiKal]

you didn't make that. it's impossible to make such a thing in PS from scratch. and frankly, i wouldn't have cared if you had said you used someone else's planets, but lying about it is bad, since i can tell when you are.

Uh... Wrong, it's really quite easy too make a planet in PS, I've done plenty. >:P

 

[Cyndaquil]

https://www.getsmf.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=18&mforum=avatarcre8tors
What 'bout those?
And here's another, I just made:

 

[Kurayami]

Could some one please comment on these avatars? ._.; I'm not sure I like how they turned out. ^^; And the little text is supposed to be un-readable. It's just there to look pretty. ^^;

 

[Kyosuke]

Overall I think they both look really nice you seemed to choose the right text and a picture to go with the overall avatar, but there is just something about the ears on the first one with the pink background, that seems a bit off ^^'

Ah first post here XD

Just something I did in PSP 8

 

[Strawberry Delcatty]

I'm sorry to sound irritated or anything, but I've yet to get a rate on my latest work.

 

[Sawyer]

hmm... okay, sorry for the accusation, and sorry for being a **** lately... i've had some "problems" recently.

 

[Yami_Zidane]

*points to sig* keep pressing refresh and give my your opinions of the 4 banners in my sig rotator ^_^

 

[Strawberry Delcatty]

I personally liked the Shaman King sig the best. The blue one was okay, but I really didn't like the Samus one.

Please rate.

 

[Sawyer]

the Samus one is definitely the best.. very tech-ish.

 

[Composer of Requiems]

https://www.getsmf.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=18&mforum=avatarcre8tors
What 'bout those?
And here's another, I just made:

Wow overall feel is very impressive but... why pixel? If you want to use pixel font or sprites, don't distort it too much ^^ I strongly recommend you find a normal art of Cyndaquil and use it instead. The usage of the Q is very good.

Just something I did in PSP 8

Ok... to be honest, I preferred your other sprite animation style.

That is about the only real usage of sprites in graphics design; mainly because, sprites are usually too pixelated. In this kind of case, it really doesn't work with the background because the background doesn't give the right kind of theme. I think if you used the flashing words and animated the sprite, then changed the background style, it would look much better.

Also, I have a problem with the usage of stocks. Unless there is some very strong theme in putting them together, it isn't really a good idea to use too many stocks at once. I suspect these 3 are part of a team (am I right?) but it isn't glaringly obvious when you first look it at; so it looks like you just put 3 random things together.

Usually if there is more than one stock in the work, then there should be some distinction/contrast to show that there is some very strong significance in using them. Otherwise, it diverts attention.

I'm sorry to sound irritated or anything, but I've yet to get a rate on my latest work.

Umm same thing; please try not to use too many stocks in the same work, and also, stocks are a bit too small. There is too much empty space. Not that empty space is a bad thing, but it doesn't flow with all themes.

 

[Strawberry Delcatty]

Umm same thing; please try not to use too many stocks in the same work, and also, stocks are a bit too small. There is too much empty space. Not that empty space is a bad thing, but it doesn't flow with all themes.

I kinda overdid it with the sprites, but that's because I was trying to get rid of the empty space. Still, it couldn't be done, but it came out good regardless in my eyes.