Graphic Rating Thread

[Lucid]

I'm old fashion, I use Paintshop Pro 7, yes, 7, for 90% of my work, I do use Photoshop CS2 for it's brushes though, because they tend to be much nicer.

And thanks for the feedback. ;)

 

[Nell]

You're welcome, Paige ;) I love my PSCS2, It's what I use for everything I do, much of my work has the Photoshop feel~

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Okay I just wanted a rating on my gfx tournament entry on another forum, I lost my 1st battle within the 2nd round, the 2nd battle is real life abstract, so I hope this time I win...

 

[Organization#13]

Here's a avy/banner combo I made 2 days ago, or so.

 

[Jedite1000]

this is my very first banner i did, i know its not good like the other members but it is my first attepted

and also i dont know how to do borders on photshop

 

[Nell]

KH: your style is pretty neat, just spice up the emptiness, it kills me, the OCD freak XD
Jedite1000: Pretty nice for a 1st, keep at it! ;)

 

[Sorano]

This is my first time posting in this thread, so go easy on me, k? xD
Okay, so here is the Hinamori Momo banner that is currently in my siggy. I was basically just experimenting with this...I wasn't planning on using it or anything. But I think it turned out okay. o__o I know there are some things that I could have done better.

 

[Lucid]

This is my first time posting in this thread, so go easy on me, k? xD
Okay, so here is the Hinamori Momo banner that is currently in my siggy. I was basically just experimenting with this...I wasn't planning on using it or anything. But I think it turned out okay. o__o I know there are some things that I could have done better.

Black and white images are love.

Realy nice, Karli, it's my favorite thing you've ever made as a matter of fact. Really pretty brushes too. You use that checkered-looking background a lot, huh? I think we can call it your trademark thing... The text is placed just so as well.
*crappy with text* D;

 

[Sorano]

Wow, thanks Paige. ♥ It's one of my favourite pieces of work, as well. It took me quite a while to do. xD; I try not to use the checkered-look all the time, but when I do I try to make it look different each time. As for the text...I usually suck with that, as well. It took me a bit to figure out where it would look best. I'm kind of uncertain about where "Karli" is located, so I might take it out.

 

[Drifblim]

As always, lovely work, Sorano. Especially your choice and style of text, which makes it grainy and pieces it into the background. I thought accepted typefaces were enough....

Anyhoo.

 

[Shooting_star*]

Aye i like it, not sure about the whiite outline though, 1 pixel black stroke may look better, but thats just my personal taste! apartfrom that, awsome 8/10 :)

 

[Tsugaru]

Well here are my latest sigs

What you think?

 

[Legobricks]

upon shinou's request

shinou pearl has asked that i rate his banners

well i like'em, fitting patterns and such 10/10 (the only imperfection IMHO being the white border of the 1st one)

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

my rating is that you should stop using dled brushes

 

[Tsugaru]

Dled brushes? what are those?

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

DLed = downloaded brushes

 

[Tsugaru]

Ohhh,Well I haven't been bothered to make my own really,I will look into it though if downloaded ones are junk,Thanks for the comments btw

 

[Sawyer]

It's not that downloaded brushes are low quality, it's that you're not using your own goddamn work.

 

[parallelzero]

It's not that downloaded brushes are low quality, it's that you're not using your own goddamn work.

Well, being the graphical genius you are, you should be able to understand that not everyone has the ability to create brushes. That's why people who aren't selfish create sets for other people to use.

 

[Tsugaru]

Exactly,If people put them up for download,Then expect them to be downloaded.Besides the banner is just filled with brushing