4th Gen HeartGold?

[CyanFlame]

I want to get HeartGold. BADLY. I already have SoulSilver, but I used Action Replay on that run so I want to play it over. So should I get it since I already have HeartGold?

 

[blue]

Well there's not much difference between the two aside the difference in Pokémon and Legendaries but I still got the both and I think it was worth it.

 

[Sydian]

Moving to 4th gen games since this ain't the right place.

 

[Kenshin5]

I wouldn't recommend it since they are pretty much the same game with different pokemon and slight differences. Here are some lists of version exclusives https://www.serebii.net/heartgoldsoulsilver/exclusives.shtml

 

[bobandbill]

If you want to keep that SS save file and don't mind playing the game again (and can find it cheap which may not be that easy as it isn't that old yet) then consider if but if you don't care about the Pokemon on your current SS file then you might as well just start a new save file on your SS game. That's basically all there is to it and there's no real right or wrong answer as it depends on your liking of the games and all, so it's up to you.

Don't see much else in the way of discussion coming from this that has already been said, and there's the Help thread sticky for any other question you may have, so I'll just close.