2nd Gen Hitmonchan vs. Pirmeape

[apples2]

^ That. Seriously.....wow....

This community is awesome.

 

[HarrisonH]

^ LOL.

To EVERYBODY that said that the Punch attacks were "NOT PHYSICAL because were in Generation II":

https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Thunderpunch

https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Fire_punch

https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Ice_Punch

^ READ. Because I don't see anywhere in Generation II that said they were Special Attacks at the time. I think we all have the logic to deduce that a PUNCH is physical, weather its on fire or not.

Your decision, really.

Hover over the *

I think we all have the logic to deduce that YOU are wrong, regardless of what you say or not.

They were not physical before generation 4. End of discussion.

 

[Teh Blazer]

Primape looks cooler than Hitmonchan. He also has better Speed and equally good Attack.

 

[apples2]

Now I can understand if Johnny was a kiddie that's about as old as Pokemon itself and never got to play the oldschool versions, but "Age: 18", and you're claiming something that is untrue, even when you link US to something where it says otherwise.

Let's break the post.

^ LOL.

To EVERYBODY that said that the Punch attacks were "NOT PHYSICAL because were in Generation II":

***I can't create U R L s because I haven't made more than 15 posts. I'm assuming this is an anti-spam tactic, because otherwise this is pointless.

^ READ.

I did and they're Specialized, so don't be capitalizing the word "read" at the rest of the community.

Because I don't see anywhere in Generation II that said they were Special Attacks at the time.

Then you need to read better.

I think we all have the logic

Obviously not.

to deduce that a PUNCH is physical,

If I punch you with a flaming fist, you're probably going to care more about the Fire on your face, rather than a simple knuckle sandwich.

weather its on fire or not.

Don't be jamming logic down our throats if you don't even know basic grammar. "Whether" and "it's" should be in there instead.

In my opinion,

I don't think that would be a good idea.

go with whichever you see more useful to you.

Pick Primeape if you want a good fighting with great attack and Speed.

Primeape sucks as a Pokemon and as a Fighting type. Machamp is much better, and the Speed isn't that important.

Pick Hitmonchan if you want a different fighting type with more unique moves.

Your decision, really.

Unique moves are definitely fun, but that doesn't mean it's good. Tri-Punch Hitmonchan sucks, but it's fun to play. Even a non-ELEMENTAL punch Hitmonchan can be silly to play with.

 

[The Hawk]

Probably Hitmonchan, he can learn Fire- Ice- Thunder- and the other elemental punch which name I have clearly forgotten.

 

[xSeduction]

Hitmonchan = cutest fighting type pokemon in the first gen.
Epic win. I'd go with Hitmonchan.
Err.. says the girly girl.
-Shrug- But I agree, if you want a more effective attack, go with Primeape.