If the gen 8 games end up being the "games of our dreams," full of content, appropriate difficulty, good story, and NOT like the "standard first games of a gen," then I'll say this was worth it. But if we end up with another XY or SM or DP, etc. as our first gen 8 games, then there's no point in splitting the games between "casual" and "hardcore."
I agree with the people who say DPP remakes should NOT be in this style as well. But something I wonder is how they can keep this up outside of Kanto. What two starter Pokémon can they use for gen 2? Espeon and Umbreon? What about gen 3, Plusle and Minun? It starts to sound silly. If they go back to "mascot legendaries" (Let's Go... Lugia and Ho-oh? Are we really going with them?), how will they handle your starter? Would you just never be able to evolve your Turtwig, your Treecko?