• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map of the week take 2!

Not really, if the maps are good enough then I will choose two from the same person.
 
I Vote for Trebuh's map...The mountains have so much detail and It looks like he put a lot of time and Effort into Them...And the Palette and Tree Placement Rocks...;)
 
Its a tough call between MASTEROFPUPPETS and Trebuh for me,

I am going to vote for Trebuh as I love the colour scheme, the mountain formation is well done and I like the placement of trees.
 
I agree with Buizel 9 on the idea of having two maps by the same person. 1) I thought there were only supposed to be five eligible maps and 2) it's just weird having two maps by one person. Their chances of winning are reduced because votes will be split between the two maps and they also draw votes away from other maps.
So yeah, that's my opinion. Take it or leave it.

I'll edit this later once I decide on who to vote for.
 
It really came down to MASTEROFPUPPETS93 and ~Trebuh~'s maps.

MASTEROFPUPPETS93's water placement is wonderful in my opinion, it looks natural. The attention paid to detail is great; The shadow under the bridge and the usage of different regular grass tiles is done well. The flower placement is good, but it's not great. It could use some work. The mountain shape is very well done too.

~Trebuh~'s mountain placement is astounding. I absolutely love it. The path placement looks good on first glance, but it's rather sporadic in spots. I really dislike how the northern pond uses different water tiles. It doesn't fit at all with the rest of the map. Tree placement is quite natural and it has sort of a quaint feeling to it. Flower placement could really use some work; there's no flowers on the right side of the map.

So, my vote goes to ~Trebuh~. I really feel that everything in the map compliments itself and the other parts around it. Sure, there are some major flaws, but the rest of the map makes up for them wonderfully.
 
colcolstyles said:
I agree with Buizel 9 on the idea of having two maps by the same person. 1) I thought there were only supposed to be five eligible maps and 2) it's just weird having two maps by one person. Their chances of winning are reduced because votes will be split between the two maps and they also draw votes away from other maps.
So yeah, that's my opinion. Take it or leave it.

I'll edit this later once I decide on who to vote for.
Click to expand...

Hmm... I made it six when I restarted this xD. Okay, well there is no rule against it. But seeing as there is popular demand:

NEW RULE: There cannot be more than one map per member each week.

The winner is:

1st - Trebuh (4 Votes)

Note: One vote didn't count of an insignificant reason.

Editing
 
I really like Trabuh's Map . it is the best one i ever saw i would give it 10000 % !
 
I Vote for Trebuh's Map
Really Nice
Neat
Awesome
That's ALl what i can say *giggles*

-Yasumin >3
 
sasquatchd00d's Map:

I like the path and the bridge in particular, it is a well executed map that looks like it would be enjoyable to play.
 
I vote for trebuh's map because it has such a great variety of trees and other vegitation.
 
This week my vote goes to haefele's map.

The naturality of this map just is mind blowing. Honestly, I can not find anything that looks out of place or awkward. There have been so many block edits done and it really shows an amazing effort put into this map. The tree placement is simply wonderful and the mountains are placed in a way that is natural looking, but not overdone. The water placement and shape is just great too. I see a lot of maps where the water is really blocky looking and it just makes me cringe. He also did a very good job of transitioning from town to beach in my opinion.

This is probably the best map I have ever seen and will see in a long time. haefele really deserves to win this week in my opinion. I can not wait to see more from him. ^_^
 
I...Too...Have fallen in love with the exquisite detail in this map...and How it still manages not to make things look crammed & Clumped together...And have a really natural feel to it...Combine this with an excellent tileset and Color scheme...this map will make anyone Gasp in astonishment...This one absolutely deserves the prize...

My Vote...Go's to Haefale...And...To the best map I've seen in a long while...
 
Seeing as this week contained no votes, the same maps will be continued into next week. The week number will stay the same, but the deadlines will change.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top