Map Rating/Review Thread

[~Teh Panda~]

I was skipped. Ya same stuff as before.

Endigo Port City:

Reason for scarce trees on bottom left and right is because it is unreachable to get there. No surfing :P

I see the tile errors on the tree rows ^^

 

[Logan]

I saw all the maps and they all are good...
Here is mine...Its not for my hack,its just a jus 4 fun map i make...
"image removed"

Um.....
1/10
I can't say anything else about it.

Endigo Port City:

Reason for scarce trees on bottom left and right is because it is unreachable to get there. No surfing :P

Spoiler:

Hmm..... I like it...
I like the city theme to it but tree tile errors xD
8/10 would of been 9

Um... Here is a starter map I made for a future hack xD
Houses will be changed so don't worry xD

Name: Inshika Town

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

Um.....
1/10
I can't say anything else about it.



Hmm..... I like it...
I like the city theme to it but tree tile errors xD
8/10 would of been 9

Um... Here is a starter map I made for a future hack xD
Houses will be changed so don't worry xD

Name: Inshika Town

The tiles are good but the map is a lil bit to regular^^ 5/10

Here a new fire red map, i create. Its a testmap of my first rombase^^

"image removed"

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Hey, all.

An FE map for you all.

 

[Eletj]

Its been awhile but here are a couple of maps~

Map Name: ??? Town
Game: Fire Red

Spoiler:

Map Name: ???
Game: Fire Red

Spoiler:

I was missed out. So.. Please Rate :nervous:

 

[machomuu]

I was missed out. So.. Please Rate :nervous:

I'll only rate the first one 5/10, bland and too direct.

 

[HungryGengar]

Map Name: Mosswood Town
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

*image removed*

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Map Name: Mosswood Town
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

*image removed*

Looks pretty great for a nice little starter town I take it?

Great looking tiles, and a nice layout make it pretty good. The fallen tree is a bit out of place though... Unless it plays importance in the hack, it is really odd looking there in this map...
There is a bit of empty space, but that is ok, since it is the starter town... never really big... lol.
I also think the sign is not exactly in the best position there at the top of the map... not on that side of the road at least... looks a bit cramped with that tree... Just letting you know.

I'll give it an 8/10

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

I think no one did see my map T~T i post it again... i inserted a few new tiles including a tree from wah... its a test-map for my rombase^^

map name: test-map
rom: fire red (GER)
comments: i'm proud of it *ö*

"image removed"

 

[CollinP]

in my opinion

I think no one did see my map T~T i post it again... i inserted a few new tiles including a tree from wah... its a test-map for my rombase^^

map name: test-map
rom: fire red (GER)
comments: i'm proud of it *ö*

"image removed"

Comments- very good map
Rating- 9/10
suggestions.... none rly

 

[Magneto20]

Map Name: Currently untitled
Map game: Fire Red

Spoiler:

please rate :)

 

[Pokepal17]

Map Name: Currently untitled
Map game: Fire Red

Spoiler:

please rate :)

8/10, it's a pretty good map

 

[amtrax]

Name: Scarlet town
Map of: Fire Red
Is the starting town

Spoiler:

Name: Route 47
Map of: Fire Red
Is located south of Scarlet Town

Spoiler:

Both Together

Spoiler:

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Name: Scarlet town
Map of: Fire Red
Is the starting town

Spoiler:

Name: Route 47
Map of: Fire Red
Is located south of Scarlet Town

Spoiler:

Both Together

Spoiler:

Well Well Well!
This looks quite wonderful indeed... the Pallet is pleasing on the eyes, the Placement of the trees is quite natural, and the house placement is wonderful...
And in the route, there is a nice amount of grass, yet there is room for the player to walk avoiding grass... I gotta say, Imma give these maps, BOTH an 8.5/10...

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

Its another map created with my rombase^^ But the version of the rombase, i posted in the romhackingresources-thread isn't the final version! However here's the map:
Credits: Alistair, WAH

"image removed"

 

[ElusionM]

Rate this map+suggestions please:

It's SUPPOSED to be the starter map; didn't take much to make, and is not my best work(I can edit if needed); don't steal either please; thx:

FIRERED
NO NAME
Oh yeah, if you can recognize the pallettes PLEASE PM me so I can credit you. I have them for quite some time but can't remember from who. Sry.

 

[colcolstyles]

Its another map created with my rombase^^ But the version of the rombase, i posted in the romhackingresources-thread isn't the final version! However here's the map:
Credits: Alistair, WAH

"image removed"

Is it just me or is the color of the blue roof directly above the window a little darker than the rest of the roof?

 

[sasquatchd00d]

Is it just me or is the color of the blue roof directly above the window a little darker than the rest of the roof?

I see it too. It's hardly noticable, but it's there nonetheless.

 

[colcolstyles]

I see it too. It's hardly noticable, but it's there nonetheless.

Good. I thought I was going crazy :D
That's odd though since the window should use the same palette as the roof. Hm, oh well.

In order to keep this post acceptable, I suppose I should add something more. Uh, I don't like the fact that the player only has one square to travel through in order to access the blue house, as well as that one red house. The sand path palette is a little weird too but that's not really mapping. Another thing I don't like is the placement of the lamppost that overlaps the path. I wouldn't mind it so much if you moved it one block south so that only the top third overlapped the path. The area south of the eastern red house seems a little empty while the area in front of the northern red house seems really cramped. But the fence usage is pretty darn good, if I may say so myself. Finally, the beach is too empty. Add some trees or something (but don't add too many more rocks or else it'll look bad).

 

[ElusionM]

Can you guys rate my map above/suggestions so I can continue with it or edit it to favor suggestions?