• Please note that this section is for questions regarding the forum itself - it is not for fan game-related questions. If you have a question about a fan game, ask in the appropriate thread.

  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Which Pokémon Masters protagonist do you like most? Let us know by casting a vote in our Masters favorite protagonist poll here!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

PC Trials

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tsukasa

KWR
    • 563
    Posts
    20
    Years
    Alright maybe PC should have trials,and yes by trials i mean like a court trial.This is mainly for the people on the verge of getting banned,it should be made so that the entire PC can decide weather or not he/she should be banned,yes i know thats what the higher staff is for but this is a community right?And as a community isnt everyone supposed to work together?

    I could understand not having one for the spammer that appeared in the Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald section,but for a member thats been here for maybe five or more months.Just like a regular court,the person will be judged by his peers (Or the people at PC).He/She should be notified maybe a week or so before the actualy date.
    Such as this:
    To:
    User

    Message:
    User you are required to attended PC Court (Yes a nice name ^^) to decide weather to be banned or given another chance.If you continue to do the actions that caused this trial then there will be no need for the trial you will be automatically banned.

    This is just suggestion.
     
    I can see what you're getting at here, which is why I must draw the line. Internet =/= real world. In the real world, you have people commiting serious offences and then being sent to court for it before being sentenced to jail. On the Internet, you have people spamming and throwing insults around. That's hardly anywhere near worth the time/effort that would be put into a court system, if implemented. ^^; I do like your perspective, chu, but there are numerous flaws in your idea and I can't really see it working out~
     
    this would be very controversial and mods would lose a lot of power/influence. i'm not sure if it's a good idea. power should be left to our staff, not to a biased pannel of jury members who could be paid off with rep or sprite requests. i'd be for it if there was a high staff member (maybe titled "Honorable Judge" or something) who decided the ultimate fate, but i don't think PC jury duty is a good idea... if this does go through, i'd be happy to be an attourney for any of those who "can't afford an attourney one will be provided to you."
     
    Digital Phoenix said:
    I can see what you're getting at here, which is why I must draw the line. Internet =/= real world. In the real world, you have people commiting serious offences and then being sent to court for it before being sentenced to jail. On the Internet, you have people spamming and throwing insults around. That's hardly anywhere near worth the time/effort that would be put into a court system, if implemented. ^^; I do like your perspective, chu, but there are numerous flaws in your idea and I can't really see it working out~
    Click to expand...
    *applauds* Nicely said...that is way too much work to have a whole court worked out for PC...quick banning is much easier XD...
     
    It is a nice idea, however, it won't be happening. People can be influenced way to easily, especially in this era of PC. >> So, like rsgh5 said, these people could be bribed very easily. I know there's a possibility that mods could be bribed, but I'm sure they were cosen because they aren't that stupid... I'm hoping anyways, XD
    Just too many things could and would go wrong ig this was used.
     
    it was a good suggestion especially in light of recent banning disputes... *looks around nervously...* (for those who don't know i kinda argued a bit about a banning *TOXIC SHAME!*) i think it would be fun even if it wouldn't be useful. maybe we could have like a mock trial. a lot of schools have mock trials for fun. that could be pretty popular. i'd do it if somebody organized it. i'd be defendent, attourney, bailiff, jourey, judge, or w/e.
     
    Wow. That's a clever idea I think, but I also dont think it would be good for PC as stated by Ty. Internet =/= real world! I wouldn't like it any different :3
     
    Why waste time doing the beauracracy of a trial when the staff can just use initiative and common sense to sanction the offender?
     
    Well like i stated in my first post this is a Community,so everyone should have a say in it.I would understand members that have just arrived not to participate in it but members that have been here for couple of months or maybe even a year.They should have a pretty good understanding of the rules of PC by then.
     
    Thats why im just posting this thread to see what everyone thinks about IF it does seem like a good idea then i guess a section or a thread will be made
     
    Tsukasa said:
    Alright maybe PC should have trials,and yes by trials i mean like a court trial.This is mainly for the people on the verge of getting banned,it should be made so that the entire PC can decide weather or not he/she should be banned,yes i know thats what the higher staff is for but this is a community right?And as a community isnt everyone supposed to work together?

    I could understand not having one for the spammer that appeared in the Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald section,but for a member thats been here for maybe five or more months.Just like a regular court,the person will be judged by his peers (Or the people at PC).He/She should be notified maybe a week or so before the actualy date.
    Such as this:
    To:
    User

    Message:
    User you are required to attended PC Court (Yes a nice name ^^) to decide weather to be banned or given another chance.If you continue to do the actions that caused this trial then there will be no need for the trial you will be automatically banned.

    This is just suggestion.
    Click to expand...

    Fair idea but, hehe...no, it wouldn't work...

    If someone was getting banned, they could just parade 20 of their buddies to keep em on. And do you think all of PC would care about a member being banned? We ban people once every 4-5 days, or more! You think members wanna have a court hearing all the time?

    It's just a simple message board, so we need simple ways of doing things. Break the rules...get a warning, keep doing it, you get a threat, keep doing it, and your banned...

    Easy! I like you're thinking though!
     
    Well this discussion is over with.A mod or anybody can close this now.I sooo wanted to be a supreme judge..XD j/k.But isee what you guys mean now by anyone could be bribed,it was a bad idea but worth a shot ^^;;
     
    Like everyone said it is a good idea, but also as stated, no it wouldn't work. But as a game, like with Pokemon Survivor games, mock trials could be made up as a game of sorts. Like rsgh5 said I think it'd be pretty popular. ^_^
     
    Per request...SQUEEE!!

    ~Locked
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top