Please Rate These!!!

[frosty]

Ok, I made some forum buttons, and I am a beginner at this... Soooo, on a scale frome one to ten, can you please rate these??? Also, I need some suggestions too... NOTE: You may use these, just let me know, please. Also note that these are not my final version...

Ok here they are...

#1

#2

#3

...I numbered them to make it easier for you to rate.

 

[Castrainer]

1, 2 and 3 - Very awesome! I like the effect ya used to make them transparent! 9.5/10

 

[Jolteon]

i like all of them!, but no.1 is a bit better!, but there all awesome!

 

[frosty]

WOW!!! Thanks... What program do most of you guys use? Me, I wish I could use Photoshop, but it's to exspensive... Right now I use a combination of the bilt image editor, for Game Maker, and MS Paint. Anyways I made a new button, but it doesn't look as good as it will with the words... well here it is...
#4

 

[Arcanine]

They are all nice Frost, but like Jolt I like the first one the best.

 

[frosty]

yeeeeeesss, I see... already #1 seems to be the most popular. So really what I need is to make the pic stretch across the button walls and base...

 

[MoonLight]

Yeah they are Very Nice buttons Frosty ^_^ #1 I really like best it's stands out more Great job on them all :)

 

[frosty]

Oh thanks for the support... Hmmm... Well I want to start a new button, but simular to #1 so people like it... Ok, I need suggestions... As in what pokemon, what base color should be, etc...

EDIT:
Ok I made two new buttons... here they are...
#5

#6

...Other elements are coming soon... by element I mean, bulbasaur, will also have charmander and squirtle.

 

[Thomas]

Are these for fudges forum?

 

[Fox_Die]

I like the bulbasaur one the best [#6] but because I could only vote 1, 2 or 3 I voted #1 because I think it looks cooler that the other two

 

[Sizor]

deoxy is stronger than the cutey that jirachi is so i vote for 2

 

[Careful With That Axe Pichu!]

one and 2 are very good. ha! also tha number three!

 

[frosty]

Are these for fudges forum?

No, these are not for Fudges Forum. I don't even think I'm a member there any more -_-... Anyways, what should I do next? Come on, come on, I need suggestions... BTW, with in time I will also take requests, but that is going to be long after I finish my own forums...

 

[psilocybin]

Hmm.. I like #3 and #5 personally. Though I'd be a bit more less blocky (in my opinion of course, don't always go by me) if you made them transparent, unless they're against a white background. But I won't really judge by that. ^_^; Not everyone can make them transparent gifs or anything.

They're very well done though. I love the bold borders for some reason. It captured my attention right to the images inside, I guess.
Love to see more. ^_^

 

[frosty]

Ok, I have two new buttons...
#7

#8

...Which one do you like better? They're both Gonbe, just to let you know...

 

[pokepac]

I think their all cool,but I think #1 is the best!I also think those two you just made our good!

 

[Thomas]

Why arent you a member there anymore? I thought you were an admin?

 

[frosty]

Why arent you a member there anymore? I thought you were an admin?

Because fudge mistreated my creations, and took advantage of me... I'll never go back!!!

 

[Estrella Oscura]

Well i think there all well made buttons realy. Though i picked #1. I like that one over all better than the others. Just my opion though

 

[Ashs_grrl]

hi frosty itsa you pair :D

can you do a raichu one for me please? those are really good! I like the jirachi cuz Jirachi rocks :D is it okay if i use them for my forum?