Rate the signature of the person above you

[Manaphy1128]

the banners and theme are really nice but two might be a little overkill. or at least how they're placed.
8/10

Two things kill yours:

Spoiler tags and giant letters. Yelling something.

I never have like either. Oh, and the claims.

So overall,

5/10

 

[Bishopk]

The banner and colors work well together, but I don't know what that's from...
Nice and simple. 9.5/10.

 

[Waffle-San]

What do people have against spoler tags anyways? I like my signature as small as possible while also getting in what i want.

Anyways, yours is different then most i see and i like that.
7.5/10

 

[~Mithos~]

well with the spoilers your signature gets HUGE way too many lines....

i'll give you a 7/10, nice picture, but limit on the writing.

 

[TwilightBlade]

7.5/10 Banner is nice but it'd be great if you organized/colored/pimpified the text a bit.. |D

 

[Manaphy1128]

lets see....Shines card...old.
Claims....old.

Overall, boring and old, un-original. Thaeres nothing really, much.

5/10

 

[.Aero]

I like yours Manaphy. The colors are great. I just don't like how big your text is. I'd make it normal size or 1. I personally like it smaller. (Maybe it's just the way my computer is. It makes text bigger than it is. Tell me so if it's normal, becuase I can't tell on this computer.)

9/10 if text is too big. 9.9/10 if the text is normal size or smaller.

~desu Saba~

 

[Phanima]

The banner seems kind of rough and the text conflicts too much with the background colour. The images of Tobi also seem king of roughly cut, and the realistic version doesn't mix well with the more cartoony one. The text outside and to the side is fine, but the colour scheme is too random for my liking.

3/10

 

[Azonic]

zomg its wierd. Whats she doing??? I don't get it. The coloring isn't too good. 3/10

 

[.Aero]

XD I got critisized on my banners already! XD Anyways, I like yours although weird.....Just great color sheme and everything. 9.5/10 Don't know why you didn't get that 0.5. It's just not perfect I guess you could say. XD

EDIT: Ooops, a little late.

Pequinpal: 2/10. Sorry but I don't really like the giant Houndoom card thingy, and the text is weird and big...

~desu Saba~

 

[Azonic]

What is it? 2/10 Its sorta wierd since the text is all on the top right. and the color scheme isn't the best. sorry

 

[Phanima]

zomg its wierd. Whats she doing??? I don't get it. The coloring isn't too good. 3/10

I think he's posing, oh and yeah, she's a guy...

@Pipluper: Haha, now you made me feel bad for critiquing you so harshly. .3.

I suppose after further deliberation, I can conclude that my previous judgement was too rushed. It has an aesthetic feel about it that after a while, it can grow on you, so +1!

4/10

@Penguinpal6: I already commented on your image a few pages back, but you've changed the text so I'll grade it again. It's just too big, more than it really needs to be, but I guess that's good, since I can read it without having to squint.

5/10

 

[Hinamori_Momo]

6/10. I like the pic and I love Dragonair.

 

[Azonic]

No banner. just a wierd red Absol and too much text.

2/10... and since you grounded me... 0

 

[Lumine]

8.8/10 nicely done and it stands out

 

[Hinamori_Momo]

7.9. Same reason as you Lumine.

And I didn't ground you Penguinpal6.

 

[Grovyle42(Griff8416)]

7/10 I'm very naive, is that a REAL family or not a real one.

 

[Xairmo]

green is a cool color, its all matching, and grovyle owns so 8/10

 

[Sir Beasty]

hmm, 5/10, i dont really like bleach.
its all about the TRIGUN!
:)

if you rate mine, will you rate my phoenix wright name?
the links in my thread.

 

[Phanima]

There's a bunch of stats and not very interestingly detailed either.

2/10

In respect to your Pheonix Wright setup, that's another story. It's a lot better than this, although kind of plain, and the Honchkrow is out of place. Could use some editing but it's better than your current one.

4/10