• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Rate the signature of the person above you

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for the rating. :3

Hm, not too fond of the banner, tbh.
I would get rid of the frame. And the text doens't really fit the banner. =/
4/10
 
I feel a little different about your signature now. After further inspection, I like the digital feel to it. 8/10.

I didn't use renders 0_o I actually used a comparitavely low quality picture and did my Corel magic on it. Yeah... I'm known for doing things different ways... Unless you're refering to the stocks. Damn termonoligy...
 
t w e n t y - t w o . said:
The CSS does make it look better, although the music player looks out of place.

5/10
Click to expand...

Well thanks for that, im sure thats JUST what i need to hear after all my hard work. three points;
1. Ive managed to use CSS which tbh, is more than you can say
2. The music player is relevant to the sig and i cant change the color of it as far as I know
3. your sig looks like someone threw up on it- its the 2nd worse ive seen here- if you think you're some kind of "expert" on designing sigs, go make a good one. Yours is like π/10. Now stop being so stingy with the marks.

As for the above, 7/10 very good sig indeed :)
Maybe could do with a tad more text in the image, but otherwise very good and highly unique
 
NickelJam® said:
Well thanks for that, im sure thats JUST what i need to hear after all my hard work. three points;
1. Ive managed to use CSS which tbh, is more than you can say
2. The music player is relevant to the sig and i cant change the color of it as far as I know
3. your sig looks like someone threw up on it- its the 2nd worse ive seen here- if you think you're some kind of "expert" on designing sigs, go make a good one. Yours is like π/10. Now stop being so stingy with the marks.
Click to expand...

Wow. You obviously have no clue how to use Photoshop well, as that is infact one of the better tags around atm, infact ask anybody in the Graphics & Photography section which of our tags are better and you might get a bit of an insight into that :/
And as for CSS, I can use CSS yes, I choose not to, infact I've made a hell of a lot more CSS signatures than you. And by out of place I mean the music player doesn't look good below the banner because it's not as wide, maybe put it on top?

Edit: There, have some CSS. Oh and I don't see you in the Graphics Battle & Collab Group, sorry :/

As for your sig. I keep my current rate. 5/10
 
Last edited:
t w e n t y - t w o . said:
Wow. You obviously have no clue how to use Photoshop well, as that is infact one of the better tags around atm, infact ask anybody in the Graphics & Photography section which of our tags are better and you might get a bit of an insight into that :/
And as for CSS, I can use CSS yes, I choose not to, infact I've made a hell of a lot more CSS signatures than you. And by out of place I mean the music player doesn't look good below the banner because it's not as wide, maybe put it on top?

As for your sig. I keep my current rate. 5/10
Click to expand...

Well tbh i couldnt care less what your opinion is on the subject- i like my sig and you have LESS THAN no right to criticize my work on some stupid set of "rules" which some guy formulated because thats what he likes. and i dont care if im a "n00b" but i dont know wth a tag is and tbh i think people have better things to do than to feed your over-inflated ego by commenting on this silly little vendetta you have against me simply because i would dare say something to the contrary of your view. Now PLEASE- stop being so childish and grow up a little.

However, i will say that your sig is actually quite nice. The scores i gave you were reflective of your own scores that you gave other people. Now im sure you dont want the opinion of a photoshop ignorant n00b like me, but i think that your sig is good, very good- but no better than anyone elses in here, and Jupiter's is just as good as yours. I am now going to give you a 7.5/10 for that reason :)

And that little change just boosted it to an 8/10, it looks a hell of a lot better than before.

EDIT: i don't want to join your graphics group, cos im too much of a n00b for it, sorry.
 
Last edited:
NickelJam® said:
Well tbh i couldnt care less what your opinion is on the subject- i like my sig and you have LESS THAN no right to criticize my work on some stupid set of "rules" which some guy formulated because thats what he likes. and i dont care if im a "n00b" but i dont know wth a tag is and tbh i think people have better things to do than to feed your over-inflated ego by commenting on this silly little vendetta you have against me simply because i would dare say something to the contrary of your view. Now PLEASE- stop being so childish and grow up a little.

However, i will say that your sig is actually quite nice. The scores i gave you were reflective of your own scores that you gave other people. Now im sure you dont want the opinion of a photoshop ignorant n00b like me, but i think that your sig is good, very good- but no better than anyone elses in here, and Jupiter's is just as good as yours. I am now going to give you a 7.5/10 for that reason :)
Click to expand...

That's a fair enough call, but I wouldn't go saying stuff like 'it looks like somebody threw up on it' unless you'e got a bit of experience in the area yeah? Anyways, if I can, I'll add some constructive critism to my rte of your sig.

Try putting the tag 'the picture' at the top, and making the CSS as wide as the tag is, then putting the rest of it underneath.
 
I have no idea what you just said there. What on my earth is a tag? Tbh, im a programmer not a graphics artist, i just thought i would give it a try.
:'/ i always seem to rub someone up the wrong way, jeez...
Sorry if i hurt your pride, but i think mine kicks @ss :)
Oh, and still 8/10
 
I like the way you used a graphic as the BG for it, but the big gaps around the sides of it look a bit tacky.
Oh and a tag is like a graphic or something. Like the picture in my sig is a tag same with .raiden's and stuff.
Lol, dw about it, no hard feelings kay?

I'm keeping the same rate, but it'd be better if you closed those borders a bit ^^ 5/10
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top