Return of Cursed Books or Earth & Sky

[Quto]

If I were to return to making a new roleplay; which would people enjoy to return to more?

Earth and Sky or Cursed Books?

To those who haven't been around when I posted these;

Earth and Sky was a Pokemon role play, taking place in a new region where in order to compete in the league, you had to beat other trainers and assemble your own league badge by collecting badge components from your opponents. There were only 2 human-run towns in the whole RP while the rest we're just basic wild territory with pokemon that would attack trainers and their teams alike, forcing the players to survive long enough to obtain their badges while racing against the clock to finish the league up before winter. This breaks the traditional formula of Pokemon completely where you travel to a town, beat a gym, wash-rise and repeat and had its spin of different fighting styles

Cursed Books is a roleplay I have run and has seen successful sign-ups time and time again. Basically, there would be one of these few books to where if 1 came into physical possesion of someone, they would be cursed with something particular and be given a super power in return. They would have to lift their curse by filling the self-writing books with events of their lives; if their curse was lifted, then they would keep the power bestowed upon themselves. I have even been writing a novel to the series and have been coming across MULTIPLE problems in getting it completed and published if that says anything at all; this RP even has it's own dead/alive cult following if you believe that.

If I did return to do an RP, I would only do one of these two. Even then, I won't be joining the heroes side; much instead, I'll be the antagonist for both of them. A lot of the problems with my roleplaying is that if I join one side, I go easy on it because I'm apart of that side. If I return to do a roleplay, I would like to see how it would turn out playing from the villains point of view.

 

[Quto]

It would probably help a little more if I said what I was going do for each RP in terms of story.

Cursed Books will be a repeat of the last time of when I attempted to do two RP's at once, but not many joined it nor have they responded to the (IC).

Earth and Sky will take place before the first two iterations, in an older age where the first human settlement is being roughly setup still on the brink of Lethia and people out in the world are begining to learn about Earth and Sky, Attempting to arrive to the island in order to obtain their wish.

 

[Quto]

I've decided to do another Earth and Sky as the Villian;

Look up Earth and Sky: Summers Twilight!
Lethia a few years before the first two iterations!..... Scrap metal, this is acting like a poorly produced video game sequel now. ... or a good one.