4th Gen Starter Pokemon....

[System!]

With the exception of DP, I've always chose the fire starter, so Cyndaquil for me! Besides, she's cute!

 

[ArchsageX]

I will choose Totodile for nostalgia's sake. He was after all my first pokemon ever.

 

[~*!*~Tatsujin Gosuto~*!*~]

I'm going for Totodile as usual


:t354:TG

 

[PiplupGHacker]

Definetly Cyndaquil. Wow, so many people mis-spelled Totodile

 

[Darkfox1525]

Cyndaquil. Always used it, always will.

 

[PiplupGHacker]

Cyndaquil. Always used it, always will.

Same here, its funny how people say cyndaquil is over rated when its clearly Totodile

Feraligatr's stats aren't even that good..

 

[Sweet Smoochum]

I've changed my mind. I think I'll use Cyndaquil in Soul Silver and Tododile in Heart Gold. (I already have Chikorita in Platinum that I could trade over.)

 

[kkaitlinn94]

I'll choose either Cyndaquil or Chikorita...I just lovee those two!
Since I just fixed my Gold and Silver games, I chose Chikorita on Gold and Cyndaquil on Silver.
Hm, guess I'll pick when I get the game

 

[ALC_Allstar]

I don't know. I am neutral to all three of them.

 

[Ai]

I'm either choosing Cyndaquil or Totodile. Apologies to Chikorita, you're still cool but not exactly my type xD Cyndaquil was my first choice when I first got Gold all those years ago. Then a later time I chose Totodile and soloed the game with him ^^ Except for HM slaves of course. Feraligatr owned all those little dragons (:

 

[Darkrai-Hero]

Cyndaquil, mainly because Typhlosion is one of my favorites.

 

[ckn]

i'll be getting soulsilver because i can't stand looking at that rainbow colored turkey lol XD.

as for starters go... yeah cyndaquil duh! i've picked fire types since r/g/b but i mean that wont stop me from getting all three anyways lol. i mean what are friends for anyways, obviously for trading!

 

[Vulpix_Trainer]

It's a toss up between Totodile & Cyndaquil. I would maybe pick Toto because that was my first starter when I played Gold version. But Cynda's second evolution is so Ridiculously CUTE!!!! <3 Quilava looks so cool. Chikorita never really clicked with me, im not the biggest fan of grass pokemon; but I do make exceptions.

But if i HAD to choose I would select Cyndaquil, then use an everstone on Quilava so he will forever look amazing :P XD

Also I'm getting Heart Gold, Ho-oh holds a special spot in my heart.

 

[ElementalKrack]

*Looks in Crystal Version for Starter* Ahh. Good times back in the day when I picked Cyndaquil... He owned every battle with me all the way. I guess I'm going to go with Cyndaquil.

 

[Echoing Song]

For the vast majority of my playthroughs of Silver and Crystal, I had chosen Cyndaquil. However, Ninetales has since become my favorite Pokemon, and I must now have it on all my teams when it is catch-able.

So I will pick Chikorita, as I have been doing with my recent playthroughs of Silver

 

[MrLKK]

Totodile All the way, Totodile on both HG and SS (Pretty sure I'm getting both)

 

[Trixstar]

i think for me its gotta be cyndaquil.. the fire type is my favourite starter.. although in the first gen i went with squirtle alot of the time.. but yeah cyndaquil :)

 

[Pokemonshe]

Female Chikorita. Chikorita > All the other starters :D.

 

[Tommy123]

Il be going for a totadile all the way. I have to have a Croconaw in my starting line up. :)

 

[GOLD.FTW]

in gold i went with Totodile and then in crystal i went with Chikorita. so ill have to give Cyndaquil a try =D