4th Gen Totodile? Cyndaquil? or Chikorita

[Weatherman Kiyoshi]

I'm going with Chrikorita.

Meganium are just that awesome. :3

 

[BowtiePenguin]

I love Chikorita, I'll probably choose it for a challenge.

But if I don't feel up to that, I'll go with Totodile. I like water types.

Cyndaquil is cute, though, I really rather like it.

I thought that picking the Grass starter was the easiest, Water was second and Fire was hardest?

Anyway, I'm picking Chikorita. It's so cute. ^^

 

[Static Pichu]

Chikorita is the hardest starter to pick at the beginning, because its weak to flying (falkner) and bug (bugsy).

But Chikorita Ftw!

 

[JLP_M]

Totodile was getting all the love at first, now Cyndaquil is catching up!

 

[lucario2009]

I'll choose cyndaquil , because the first two gyms are not so hard with it.

 

[BowtiePenguin]

Chikorita is the hardest starter to pick at the beginning, because its weak to flying (falkner) and bug (bugsy).

But Chikorita Ftw!

Oh yeah, I totally forgot about that. I'm still sticking with Chiky though.

 

[JLP_M]

Oh yeah, I totally forgot about that. I'm still sticking with Chiky though.

you like the challenge huh!

 

[ShinoRich]

Cyndaquil rules. A lot of the gyms are a breeze with it and it's evolutions.

 

[Haza]

Cyndaquil. hes the cutest ansd my fave of them all.

 

[blue]

If you think about it, Feraligatr could beat ALL Johto Gyms Super Effectively,

Falkner (Flying) - Ice Punch/Fang/Beam
Bugsy (Bug) - Ice Punch/Fang/Beam
Whitney (Normal.. Hardest) - Superpower (Fighting)
Morty (Ghost) - Bite (Dark)
Chuck (Fighting) Aerial Ace - TM (Flying)
Jasmine (Steel) - SuperPower (Fighting)
Pryce (Ice) - SuperPower (Fighting)
Clair (Dragon) - Ice Punch/Fang/Beam

 

[AsugetRanzo]

I'm choosing Cyndaquil. He's one of my favorites.
:]

 

[JLP_M]

No Love for Chikorita! lol

 

[Pirate Dave]

On HG I'll reset for nature with Cyndaquil and then EV train on Platinum I think, before trading him back to HG, then on SS I will trade myself an Abra or something from HG and use that as a kind of pseudo-starter. :D

Very excited for HGSS!! :D:D

 

[シーツー]

I personally prefer Totodile but as I want to have Suicune as my water Pokémon in the story line I'll choose Cyndaquil.
Cyndaquil was also my starter Pokémon in Gold...

 

[Hatenko]

Cyndaquil's really cute and Chikorita's a total wimp, but Totodile definitely outweighs both of them in badassness.

 

[Anzel]

Well, normally I choose Cyndaquil just because I like Quilava...but the only time I ever got my starter really strong was with Totodile, SO...I'll choose him!

 

[Ruphire]

For HG, I'm going to get Tododile,

And for SS, I'm going to get Cyndaquil.

 

[Napalm]

Totodile. Seems to the best choice in my opinion, I thought out of the three, it was not too novice or too hard to raise.

 

[Evil Sonic]

My favorite type is water who do you think I'll pick?

I still do not like how Feraligatr looks like so I'm keeping my Totodile a Croconaw when evolved.

 

[Guns]

Totodile. It's what I chose in my original Gold Version.